Gratuit avec l'essai de 30 jours
-
The Other Side of History: Daily Life in the Ancient World
- Narrateur(s): Robert Garland
- Durée: 24 h et 28 min
Échec de l'ajout au panier.
Échec de l'ajout à la liste d'envies.
Échec de la suppression de la liste d’envies.
Échec du suivi du balado
Ne plus suivre le balado a échoué
Acheter pour 66,36$
Aucun mode de paiement valide enregistré.
Nous sommes désolés. Nous ne pouvons vendre ce titre avec ce mode de paiement
Vous pourriez aussi aimer...
-
No Excuses: Existentialism and the Meaning of Life
- Auteur(s): Robert C. Solomon, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Robert C. Solomon
- Durée: 12 h et 7 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
What is life? What is my place in it? What choices do these questions obligate me to make? More than a half-century after it burst upon the intellectual scene - with roots that extend to the mid-19th century - Existentialism's quest to answer these most fundamental questions of individual responsibility, morality, and personal freedom, life has continued to exert a profound attraction.
-
-
Very well organized and easy enough to understand
- Écrit par Amanda le 2023-02-18
Auteur(s): Robert C. Solomon, Autres
-
The Classical School
- The Birth of Economics in 20 Enlightened Lives
- Auteur(s): Callum Williams
- Narrateur(s): Sean Patrick Hopkins
- Durée: 9 h et 41 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
What was Adam Smith really talking about when he mentioned the "invisible hand"? Did Karl Marx really predict the end of capitalism? Did Thomas Malthus (from whose name the word Malthusian derives) really believe that famines were desirable? In The Classical School, Callum Williams debunks popular myths about these great economists and explains the significance of their ideas in an engaging way.
Auteur(s): Callum Williams
-
Understanding the Mysteries of Human Behavior
- Auteur(s): Mark Leary, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Mark Leary
- Durée: 12 h et 11 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Every day of your life is spent surrounded by mysteries that involve what appear to be rather ordinary human behaviors. What makes you happy? Where did your personality come from? Why do you have trouble controlling certain behaviors? Why do you behave differently as an adult than you did as an adolescent?Since the start of recorded history, and probably even before, people have been interested in answering questions about why we behave the way we do.
-
-
Decent overview, but unsurprising and unoriginal
- Écrit par Utilisateur anonyme le 2020-02-02
Auteur(s): Mark Leary, Autres
-
The Habsburgs
- To Rule the World
- Auteur(s): Martyn Rady
- Narrateur(s): Simon Boughey
- Durée: 14 h et 58 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
The definitive history of a powerful family dynasty who dominated Europe for centuries - from their rise to power to their eventual downfall.
-
-
Excellent History
- Écrit par L. C. le 2020-10-05
Auteur(s): Martyn Rady
-
Food: A Cultural Culinary History
- Auteur(s): Ken Albala, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Ken Albala
- Durée: 18 h et 22 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Eating is an indispensable human activity. As a result, whether we realize it or not, the drive to obtain food has been a major catalyst across all of history, from prehistoric times to the present. Epicure Jean-Anthelme Brillat-Savarin said it best: "Gastronomy governs the whole life of man."
-
-
This is a Western food history course
- Écrit par Utilisateur anonyme le 2019-05-15
Auteur(s): Ken Albala, Autres
-
Babylon
- Mesopotamia and the Birth of Civilization
- Auteur(s): Paul Kriwaczek
- Narrateur(s): Derek Perkins
- Durée: 12 h et 1 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Civilization was born 8,000 years ago, between the floodplains of the Tigris and Euphrates rivers, when migrants from the surrounding mountains and deserts began to create increasingly sophisticated urban societies. In the cities that they built, half of human history took place. In Babylon, Paul Kriwaczek tells the story of Mesopotamia from the earliest settlements seven thousand years ago to the eclipse of Babylon in the sixth century BCE. Bringing the people of this land to life in vibrant detail, the author chronicles the rise and fall of power during this period.
-
-
A good introduction to the history of Mesopotamia
- Écrit par Mauro le 2019-09-19
Auteur(s): Paul Kriwaczek
-
No Excuses: Existentialism and the Meaning of Life
- Auteur(s): Robert C. Solomon, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Robert C. Solomon
- Durée: 12 h et 7 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
What is life? What is my place in it? What choices do these questions obligate me to make? More than a half-century after it burst upon the intellectual scene - with roots that extend to the mid-19th century - Existentialism's quest to answer these most fundamental questions of individual responsibility, morality, and personal freedom, life has continued to exert a profound attraction.
-
-
Very well organized and easy enough to understand
- Écrit par Amanda le 2023-02-18
Auteur(s): Robert C. Solomon, Autres
-
The Classical School
- The Birth of Economics in 20 Enlightened Lives
- Auteur(s): Callum Williams
- Narrateur(s): Sean Patrick Hopkins
- Durée: 9 h et 41 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
What was Adam Smith really talking about when he mentioned the "invisible hand"? Did Karl Marx really predict the end of capitalism? Did Thomas Malthus (from whose name the word Malthusian derives) really believe that famines were desirable? In The Classical School, Callum Williams debunks popular myths about these great economists and explains the significance of their ideas in an engaging way.
Auteur(s): Callum Williams
-
Understanding the Mysteries of Human Behavior
- Auteur(s): Mark Leary, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Mark Leary
- Durée: 12 h et 11 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Every day of your life is spent surrounded by mysteries that involve what appear to be rather ordinary human behaviors. What makes you happy? Where did your personality come from? Why do you have trouble controlling certain behaviors? Why do you behave differently as an adult than you did as an adolescent?Since the start of recorded history, and probably even before, people have been interested in answering questions about why we behave the way we do.
-
-
Decent overview, but unsurprising and unoriginal
- Écrit par Utilisateur anonyme le 2020-02-02
Auteur(s): Mark Leary, Autres
-
The Habsburgs
- To Rule the World
- Auteur(s): Martyn Rady
- Narrateur(s): Simon Boughey
- Durée: 14 h et 58 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
The definitive history of a powerful family dynasty who dominated Europe for centuries - from their rise to power to their eventual downfall.
-
-
Excellent History
- Écrit par L. C. le 2020-10-05
Auteur(s): Martyn Rady
-
Food: A Cultural Culinary History
- Auteur(s): Ken Albala, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Ken Albala
- Durée: 18 h et 22 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Eating is an indispensable human activity. As a result, whether we realize it or not, the drive to obtain food has been a major catalyst across all of history, from prehistoric times to the present. Epicure Jean-Anthelme Brillat-Savarin said it best: "Gastronomy governs the whole life of man."
-
-
This is a Western food history course
- Écrit par Utilisateur anonyme le 2019-05-15
Auteur(s): Ken Albala, Autres
-
Babylon
- Mesopotamia and the Birth of Civilization
- Auteur(s): Paul Kriwaczek
- Narrateur(s): Derek Perkins
- Durée: 12 h et 1 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Civilization was born 8,000 years ago, between the floodplains of the Tigris and Euphrates rivers, when migrants from the surrounding mountains and deserts began to create increasingly sophisticated urban societies. In the cities that they built, half of human history took place. In Babylon, Paul Kriwaczek tells the story of Mesopotamia from the earliest settlements seven thousand years ago to the eclipse of Babylon in the sixth century BCE. Bringing the people of this land to life in vibrant detail, the author chronicles the rise and fall of power during this period.
-
-
A good introduction to the history of Mesopotamia
- Écrit par Mauro le 2019-09-19
Auteur(s): Paul Kriwaczek
-
The Dead Sea Scrolls
- Auteur(s): Gary A. Rendsburg, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Gary A. Rendsburg
- Durée: 12 h et 21 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Whether complete or only fragmentary, the 930 extant Dead Sea Scrolls irrevocably altered how we look at and understand the foundations of faith and religious practice. Now you can get a comprehensive introduction to this unique series of archaeological documents, and to scholars' evolving understanding of their authorship and significance, with these 24 lectures. Learn what the scrolls are, what they contain, and how the insights they offered into religious and ancient history came into focus.
-
-
Fantastic
- Écrit par Laverdm le 2023-04-21
Auteur(s): Gary A. Rendsburg, Autres
-
The Psychopath Inside
- A Neuroscientist's Personal Journey into the Dark Side of the Brain
- Auteur(s): James Fallon
- Narrateur(s): Walter Dixon
- Durée: 4 h et 58 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
The memoir of a neuroscientist whose research led him to a bizarre personal discovery, James Fallon had spent an entire career studying how our brains affect our behavior when his research suddenly turned personal. While studying brain scans of several family members, he discovered that one perfectly matched a pattern he’d found in the brains of serial killers. This meant one of two things: Either his family’s scans had been mixed up with those of felons or someone in his family was a psychopath.
-
-
a little overwhelming
- Écrit par Natalie le 2018-06-15
Auteur(s): James Fallon
-
Shuttle, Houston
- My Life in the Center Seat of Mission Control
- Auteur(s): Paul Dye
- Narrateur(s): John Pruden
- Durée: 11 h et 42 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
A compelling look inside the Space Shuttle missions that helped lay the groundwork for the Space Age, Shuttle, Houston explores the determined personalities, technological miracles, and 11th-hour saves that have given us human spaceflight. Relaying stories of missions (and their grueling training) in vivid detail, Paul Dye, NASA's longest-serving flight director, examines the split-second decisions that the directors and astronauts were forced to make in a field where mistakes are unthinkable and errors led to the loss of national resources - and more importantly one's crew.
-
-
wanted more
- Écrit par aero_costas le 2022-11-10
Auteur(s): Paul Dye
-
The History of the Ancient World
- From the Earliest Accounts to the Fall of Rome
- Auteur(s): Susan Wise Bauer
- Narrateur(s): John Lee
- Durée: 26 h et 20 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
This is the first volume in a bold new series that tells the stories of all peoples, connecting historical events from Europe to the Middle East to the far coast of China, while still giving weight to the characteristics of each country. Susan Wise Bauer provides both sweeping scope and vivid attention to the individual lives that give flesh to abstract assertions about human history. This narrative history employs the methods of "history from beneath" - literature, epic traditions, private letters, and accounts - to connect kings and leaders with the lives of those they ruled.
-
-
Iffy narration, abrupt ending
- Écrit par Micah Clark le 2020-09-07
Auteur(s): Susan Wise Bauer
-
Your Deceptive Mind: A Scientific Guide to Critical Thinking Skills
- Auteur(s): Steven Novella, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Steven Novella
- Durée: 12 h et 39 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
No skill is more important in today's world than being able to think about, understand, and act on information in an effective and responsible way. What's more, at no point in human history have we had access to so much information, with such relative ease, as we do in the 21st century. But because misinformation out there has increased as well, critical thinking is more important than ever. These 24 rewarding lectures equip you with the knowledge and techniques you need to become a savvier, sharper critical thinker in your professional and personal life.
-
-
Great book worth a listen but maybe I'm bias.
- Écrit par Martin le 2018-01-15
Auteur(s): Steven Novella, Autres
-
Genghis Khan and the Making of the Modern World
- Auteur(s): Jack Weatherford
- Narrateur(s): Jonathan Davis, Jack Weatherford
- Durée: 14 h et 20 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
The Mongol army led by Genghis Khan subjugated more lands and people in 25 years than the Romans did in 400. In nearly every country the Mongols conquered, they brought an unprecedented rise in cultural communication, expanded trade, and a blossoming of civilization.
-
-
Great story, annoying music
- Écrit par Rob Smith le 2020-07-18
Auteur(s): Jack Weatherford
-
Miseducated
- A Memoir
- Auteur(s): Brandon P. Fleming, Cornel West - foreword
- Narrateur(s): Brandon P. Fleming, Landon Woodson
- Durée: 10 h et 45 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Brandon P. Fleming grew up in an abusive home and was shuffled through school, his passing grades a nod to his skill on the basketball court, not his presence in the classroom. He turned to the streets and drug deals by 14, saved only by the dream of basketball stardom. When he suffered a career-ending injury during his first semester at a Division I school, he dropped out of college, toiling on an assembly line, until depression drove him to the edge. Miraculously, his life was spared. Returning to college, Fleming was determined to reinvent himself as a scholar.
-
-
Inspirational and eye opening for all!
- Écrit par Gabriela Raymond le 2021-12-28
Auteur(s): Brandon P. Fleming, Autres
-
1066: The Year That Changed Everything
- Auteur(s): Jennifer Paxton, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Jennifer Paxton
- Durée: 3 h
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
With this exciting and historically rich six-lecture course, experience for yourself the drama of this dynamic year in medieval history, centered on the landmark Norman Conquest. Taking you from the shores of Scandinavia and France to the battlefields of the English countryside, these lectures will plunge you into a world of fierce Viking warriors, powerful noble families, politically charged marriages, tense succession crises, epic military invasions, and much more.
-
-
1066
- Écrit par Alicia Roy le 2019-01-02
Auteur(s): Jennifer Paxton, Autres
-
The Now Habit
- Auteur(s): Neil Fiore Ph.D.
- Narrateur(s): Neil Fiore Ph.D.
- Durée: 7 h et 29 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
If you are a professional, manager, student, entrepreneur, writer, or homemaker, this audiobook will help you achieve your goals more rapidly, whether they are large, complex challenges or the small, essential tasks of everyday life and work. If you now work effectively, even though you have too much to do and too little time, The Now Habit will show you how to prioritize your goals to allow more time for guilt-free play.
-
-
Decent but nothing new
- Écrit par Sarah le 2022-09-19
Auteur(s): Neil Fiore Ph.D.
-
The Many Hidden Worlds of Quantum Mechanics
- Auteur(s): Sean Carroll, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Sean Carroll
- Durée: 11 h et 51 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
In a field known for startling ideas, the Many-Worlds Interpretation (MWI) of quantum mechanics may take the prize. It holds that parallel to our own world are a large number of other universes, almost identical to ours but with small variations. Copies of each of us inhabit a myriad of these worlds. But they are not us exactly; they share our past history, but they are different people who have unique futures. Although these realms are invisible and can’t communicate with each other, prominent physicists are convinced they must exist.
Auteur(s): Sean Carroll, Autres
-
Ancient Civilizations of North America
- Auteur(s): Edwin Barnhart, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Edwin Barnhart
- Durée: 12 h et 19 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
For the past few hundred years, most of what we’ve been taught about the native cultures of North America came from reports authored by the conquerors and colonizers who destroyed them. Now - with the technological advances of modern archaeology and a new perspective on world history - we are finally able to piece together their compelling true stories. In Ancient Civilizations of North America, Professor Edwin Barnhart, Director of the Maya Exploration Center, will open your eyes to a fascinating world you never knew existed - even though you’ve been living right next to it, or even on top of it.
-
-
Most of Canada is left out, as usual
- Écrit par Amazon Customer le 2022-03-14
Auteur(s): Edwin Barnhart, Autres
-
The Roman Empire: From Augustus to the Fall of Rome
- Auteur(s): Gregory S. Aldrete, The Great Courses
- Narrateur(s): Gregory S. Aldrete
- Durée: 12 h et 41 min
- Production originale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
The Roman Empire: From Augustus to the Fall of Rome traces the breathtaking history from the empire’s foundation by Augustus to its Golden Age in the 2nd century CE through a series of ever-worsening crises until its ultimate disintegration. Taught by acclaimed Professor Gregory S. Aldrete of the University of Wisconsin-Green Bay, these 24 captivating lectures offer you the chance to experience this story like never before, incorporating the latest historical insights that challenge our previous notions of Rome’s decline.
-
-
Amazing overview
- Écrit par Joey le 2023-11-29
Auteur(s): Gregory S. Aldrete, Autres
Description
Look beyond the abstract dates and figures, kings and queens, and battles and wars that make up so many historical accounts. Over the course of 48 richly detailed lectures, Professor Garland covers the breadth and depth of human history from the perspective of the so-called ordinary people, from its earliest beginnings through the Middle Ages.
The past truly comes alive as you take a series of imaginative leaps into the world of history's anonymous citizens, people such as a Greek soldier marching into battle in the front row of a phalanx; an Egyptian woman putting on makeup before attending an evening party with her husband; a Greek citizen relaxing at a drinking party with the likes of Socrates; a Roman slave captured in war and sent to work in the mines; and a Celtic monk scurrying away with the Book of Kells during a Viking invasion.
Put yourself in the sandals of ordinary people and discover what it was like to be among history's 99%. What did these everyday people do for a living? What was their home like? What did they eat? What did they wear? What did they do to relax? What were their beliefs about marriage? Religion? The afterlife?
This extraordinary journey takes you across space and time in an effort to be another person - someone with whom you might not think you have anything at all in common - and come away with an incredible sense of interconnectedness. You'll see the range of possibilities of what it means to be human, making this a journey very much worth taking.
PLEASE NOTE: When you purchase this title, the accompanying reference material will be available in your Library section along with the audio.
D'autres livres audio du même...
auteur:
Ce que les auditeurs disent de The Other Side of History: Daily Life in the Ancient World
Moyenne des évaluations de clientsÉvaluations – Cliquez sur les onglets pour changer la source des évaluations.
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Trent T
- 2018-10-29
Loved it!
I've always enjoyed learning about history, but I've always thought that most of history focuses on the powerful elite, Kings, Emperors and the wars they fought, etc. I've often wondered what the mundane details of life were like for the common person. What beliefs did they hold? What was their daily routine like? If you are like me in this regard, then you absolutely have to get this lecture series. The professor does an amazing job at bringing the details of daily ancient life into focus. Historical writings have left out so many of the details of what life was really like, and the professor does an incredible job at them in.
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
20 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Shawn Ricker
- 2018-06-20
A must have for anyone with a interest in history.
I've listened to a handful of the great courses, and by far this is the most interesting well laid out one I've come across yet. if you want to know everything there is to know about ancient civilizations from the dawn of humans until the middle ages ~1400 CE. this is the course for you.
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
14 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- C. Scott
- 2019-02-01
Emotional journey
This was a wonderful group of lectures and I was surprised at how emotional I felt at the end. I felt as though I was saying goodbye to close and distant relatives. The Narrator asked, at the end, “Do you think that you are closer, or less close, to these everyday people, than you were before?” I would have to say that I was less close for the most part. I had a Hollywood version of what people were like in ancient times. I’ve read great Novels and seen several movies but those characters are nothing like the people of the Middle Ages or Ancient Greece or Sparta or Egypt. Life was hard. Work was back breaking and life expectancy was short. Education was almost non-existent and whether you worked on a farm or toiled in the military, life was rough. By the end of the presentation I had put my feet in the sandals of several men and even some women! And I tried to feel their trials and their joy. As we said goodbye I had a very real, familial, empathy for the people that brought us all to the modern world.
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
8 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- robin
- 2019-12-31
Sounds like robot
Difficult to listen to the narrator. He pauses after each word, making it sound like the words are chopped and pasted together or like a robot is reading. Sounds like individual words, not a sentence. So distracting. Otherwise the stories are interesting. They don’t go too in depth, just a brief overview of different cultures and time periods. Kind of disappointing.
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
7 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- C Shieh
- 2018-03-13
Informative and engaging with excellent delivery
I really enjoyed this course by Professor Garland. His knowledge on the course subject is evident; he provides an informative overview of thousands of years of history, showing glimpses of everyday life in different cultures and eras. Professor Garland really paints a realistic picture of what life was like for people throughout history in the western ancient world.
It is understandable that he could not go into too much details on every period or aspect of history (then this course would be 100+ hours!), but he provides enough information for a good understanding of the subject discussed, with room to do more personal research if wanted to.
I highly recommend this course to history lovers.
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
4 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Utilisateur anonyme
- 2020-01-20
Riveting!!!
What an amazing journey through time!
Absolutely amazing, fascinating, a fabulous listen !!!! I would definitely recommend it.
Beata
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
2 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Edward Jackowiak
- 2019-09-01
Historical daily lives.
I found it very interesting and entertaining. It added more to my knowledge of the ancient world.
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
2 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Joan M
- 2023-03-01
Interesting
The most interesting part of history are the human stories. I enjoy this perspective. Kept me interested all the way through. I found myself wanting to make up fictions about the people in every age here. can some author do that for me? Maybe I will do it myself ...
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
1 personne a trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- J Brandon.
- 2022-12-23
One of the best courses yet.
The lecturer has great passion for his work and does a wonderful job of sharing it. He injects a bit more personal opinion into this account than most historians would, but only in the best way and it’s much to the benefit. I only wish it had been longer.
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
1 personne a trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- tegan
- 2022-09-19
Incredible Knowledge and Passion
I greatly enjoyed this man's writing, passion and narration. He clearly knows his stuff and loves his work. I learned a great deal about the ancient world and how it affects us now. Especially word origins and customs.
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
1 personne a trouvé cela utile