AUDITEUR

Jon Ross

  • 24
  • commentaires
  • 7
  • votes utiles
  • 64
  • évaluations

My son’s feedback is that it’s ok but...

Au global
2 out of 5 stars
Performance
3 out of 5 stars
Histoire
2 out of 5 stars

Évalué le: 2020-05-22

My son was quite upset that this book wasn’t a continuation of the first book in the series. He was also annoyed by all the things that were against the rules of minecraft that the characters were doing.

Normally he is over the moon for any minecraft tangential related things so a muted response speaks much longer than if he was just complaining about it all.

My daughter (5) listens to this book over and over

Au global
4 out of 5 stars
Performance
5 out of 5 stars
Histoire
2 out of 5 stars

Évalué le: 2020-05-17

My daughter loves this series and I am locked in to getting it all.

As an adult I hate these books so much. I can’t enter the world as there is almost no descriptions of anything (from the format I think these are colourfully illustrated kids books for grades 1-3) and if you think about any of the details you get ejected. As a spoiler our heroes outnumber, have three dragons and disarm a crisis of the moment but still run away as if their souls were on the line. I am also unclear as to how a character who couldn’t write a letter home in book one can only a couple of weeks later scour a book on dragon lore for a cure.

But my daughter loves the series and I am doomed to get them all. And as they have over twenty queued up that shall be a book a week for a while I fear.

My Daughter (5) loves this series

Au global
4 out of 5 stars
Performance
5 out of 5 stars
Histoire
3 out of 5 stars

Évalué le: 2020-05-17

My daughter loves these books. I am going to get the series because of her.

I Hate these stories sooo much from an adult perspective. All the problems come up as a crisis of the moment and get swatted down in the next paragraph. The characters have no depth, no complexity and the world doesn’t make any sense if you think about any of the details.

The format of 45 minute tales likely comes from the print books being colourful illustrated books for grades 1-3 and I suspect target audience loves them as much as my kid. I just wish there was more, anything, to hold onto as an adult going through the story myself.

So the rating is how my daughter feels, but the words in the review mine.

Condensed and polished versions of the tales from the podcast

Au global
5 out of 5 stars
Performance
5 out of 5 stars
Histoire
4 out of 5 stars

Évalué le: 2020-05-10

If you are already familiar with the original podcast ‘Last Podcast on the Left’ you are going to find more of their polished approach to true crime stories. A long time listener to the podcast none of the tales here were new to me, but where in the podcast they have more back and forth as they talk about details for this work they have cleaned it all up to a very tight focused approach on each of the killers discussed here.
I hope this work is successful enough they can produce a long string of these covering and cleaning up further many of the tales already approached on their podcast.
If you don’t know their work they have one serious researcher who digs into the horror and two goofball friends to have read the material and attempt to break the grim seriousness with some measured and well timed humour breaks. The Humour doesn’t kick one out of the tale nor is it only dark sarcasm. It does feel like the right amount. And this is the second time they have approached each of these stories they know what details to dwell on and which to gloss over in the retelling.

You know those boring guys who trap you at events?

Au global
1 out of 5 stars
Performance
1 out of 5 stars
Histoire
2 out of 5 stars

Évalué le: 2019-12-20

Sorry, but this title isn’t for me at all. The ideas are not original (as the author admits off the top) and not presented in a fun, original or even energetic manner.

Instead we get a dull, monotonous monotone breakdown of others ideas dumped on you by someone who clearly cares but hasn’t any idea on how to dress up the material or even read out loud. There isn’t a flow you get with a professional reader.

I don’t suggest getting this work, and I hate to stomp on another’s work when they seem to care... but a professional reader and a harsh, adversarial editor that can polish up the authors knowledge would be what I would suggest.

Half comedic parody, half thinking book

Au global
3 out of 5 stars
Performance
5 out of 5 stars
Histoire
5 out of 5 stars

Évalué le: 2019-07-04

I enjoyed this book when I first read it on dead tree media years ago. Picked it up again as I saw it was part of a sale on Audible.

As a result I really did enjoy the second go at the story but I can see why others weren't as happy. John Scalzi has fun weaving good questions into his humorous approach but on the page the eye skips over the:
A said 'Yes'
B said 'therefore'
A said 'We die'
dialogue as just Yes, therefore, we die and your brain is sorting out who is doing the talking. In this audiobook there are a couple of short conversations in which it isn't quite as easy to tell who is who as Will Wheaton doesn't do a thousand different voices (a strength that he doesn't try if you ask me ;)

I really liked it, as it is a fun poke with a stick of a genre and a franchise as well as some good questions, if not answered, at least explored.

Listened to it after watching the TV series

Au global
5 out of 5 stars
Performance
5 out of 5 stars
Histoire
5 out of 5 stars

Évalué le: 2019-07-03

I own a paper copy of this book and read it in advance of watching the TV series recently (to this review) released. So I have to say that this review might best be taken with a grain of salt.

This is a fun story. Consuming it in three different ways in the course of a week, each time enjoying the work, catching different details, perhaps warns of how much I truly enjoyed it. I originally read the book years ago (when it was first released I think, if not then shortly after) and then a couple of times since. Terry Pratchett remains one of my favourite authors and Neil Gaiman isn't much further down the list.

We have the story woven from two authors, each bringing their voice to different aspects of the whole. In the book there isn't as often a jarring shift when we have the Tadpole village sections (which others have attributed to Terry Pratchett - I cannot say if their assessment is true or not) to the Angel/Demon team-up trying to save the world story aspects. The TV series wasn't quite as smooth as the book, trimming the story a touch to shape it in what is half the duration of the audiobook.

So we have more time with each of the minor characters, almost all getting at least three appearances in the book. We learn about the other four horsemen of the apocalypse and other details of humorous intent.

I enjoy the story a great deal. Having the ability to listen to it while I work on other things was great and I know I will return to this story at least once a year. The reading here is great and I had no issues at all with it. Overall, if you watched the TV show - the book is better. This is a great way to get the book.

4 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

The 100% of the money going to US vets helps

Au global
5 out of 5 stars
Performance
5 out of 5 stars
Histoire
3 out of 5 stars

Évalué le: 2019-07-03

This is a fun little 3 minute story padded out to 8 minutes with some banter between Stephen Colbert and Tom Hanks. The audible version includes a PDF of the pictures from the book (interestedly not the 40 or so sentences that make up the whole of the story) but having the PDF up while the book plays was fun enough.

Not a heroine I can get along with

Au global
1 out of 5 stars
Performance
4 out of 5 stars
Histoire
2 out of 5 stars

Évalué le: 2019-07-03

I didn't like this story overall. The heroine and our POV character just isn't one I could enjoy being inside the head of.

She wasn't the first female heroine POV character I've read/listened to but the insecurities and self-doubt just ate at my possible enjoyment of the story so consistently that I really questioned how this character got up most mornings. In conversations with others about this sort of female character (not related to this book specifically) I understood that some readers can really identify with such a person. One who can't go past a mirror without thinking they are too fat or who looks at every male character and rates how quickly they would like to strip them.

To be fair on the last point when I have a male POV character who is doing that I also check out.

The book is 8 hours long, at least half the dialogue is inside the characters own head. If it became a movie without a voice over the story could be shown inside a tight 90 minute run time. Maybe a poorly edited 120. Very little plot happens, the clues to the mystery are there but some leaps have to be made to reach the final conclusion.

Others have rated this book much higher than I and the series seems to be quite popular. I just couldn't handle the character through whom the world was being presented.

Not going to go for a refund on the book as A) The quality of the performance wasn't bad and B) I wasn't the only one who listened to it, but it's my account so I get to leave the review.

Slices of various quality stitched together for a solid whole

Au global
4 out of 5 stars
Performance
4 out of 5 stars
Histoire
5 out of 5 stars

Évalué le: 2018-12-04

This ‘book’ is a bunch of short programs with Martin Sheen as a short of narrator linking together clips of period recordings and historians talking on different themes. Selected bits of archived material, framed by a historian, framed by Martin Sheen, linked into repeating offerings of the same. At the bottom some bits aren’t the best, some of the episodes didn’t have quite enough filling and others felt cut short to fit whatever the original release format was.
As a whole recommended.