In 2009, a Florida family gathered for what should have been a warm, ordinary Thanksgiving, until the night erupted into one of the most devastating family massacres in modern true-crime history. Paul Michael Merhige, long described as the "golden child" with a quiet brilliance and a history of untreated mental illness, arrived at his relatives' home in Jupiter with a calculated plan he had concealed for years. Before the night was over, four family members were dead. In this episode, we trace the years of decline that led to that holiday tragedy, the red flags, and the chilling callous behind Merhige's actions. Through the lens of his Virgo Sun, and the influence of Virgo Mars and Virgo Venus, we explore how perfectionism, suppressed rage, and internalized resentment fused into a catastrophic breaking point on a night meant for gratitude.

SHOW NOTES:

Connect with us across streaming platforms and social media, and explore ways to support our work through our Linktree.

Cosmic Crimes Podcast Linktree

If you are new to astrology and/or are getting lost or confused during the episodes, we created a free guide of all-things-astrology on Substack for you to reference so you can listen along with ease. Click the link below!

Astrology Basics

SOURCES:

"2009 Thanksgiving murders." Wikipedia, last updated 2025.

"Thanksgiving Killer Pleads Guilty, Avoids Death Penalty." NBC Miami, 27 Oct. 2011.

"Merhige Sentenced to 7 Consecutive Terms of Life in Prison." Palm Beach Post, 27 Oct. 2011.

"Report: Paul Merhige Will Accept Plea Deal." CBS News Miami, 26 Oct. 2011.

"Parents Cleared on Son's Thanksgiving Murders." Courthouse News Service, 25 Feb. 2014.

Knight v. Merhige, 133 So. 3d 1140 (Fla. 4th DCA 2014).

A&E True Crime. "3 Grisly Thanksgiving Family Murders That Will Make You Hug Your Family Tighter This Season." AE Network, Nov. 2022.

ABC News. "Manhunt for Thanksgiving Day Killer." Nov. 27 2009.

Palm Beach Post. "Family Struggled to Help Paul Merhige Before Murders." Nov. 30 2009.

Courthouse News. "Knight v. Merhige Appeal Filed in Florida." 2014.