Great

It didn't end how I expected. I didn't know that was going to happen to Hollyleaf.
SPOILER:
But really, she just didn't what she murdered Ashfur for. Uhm, that's not right. Sorry for the spoiler.

4 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Sad but great story ok performance

The end was so sad there were so many feelings at the last chapter but a very well thought out story and good performance although I particularly like the voice of hollyleaf although I love the voice of Jayfeather.

2 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Woah

This book was a rollercoaster of emotions for me. This book series gets better with ever book so many twist and turns that i did not expect.

2 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

love the warriors series

I am biased because I love the entire series! of course I recommend reading all of the warriors books! and read them in order! by itself this book would make 0 sense so you gotta read every warriors book! this is not my favorite warriors book but did I enjoy listening to it? yes!! do I intend to listen to the next book and every book after until I've read every single book? well I have to!!! but yeah don't just pick one random warriors book and read it by itself. I imagine that would be super confusing. this book alone without the context of all the books before it would just be confusing and you wouldn't enjoy it as much.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

The big reveal

I am re-reading this as an adult so I'm not going to go into the dramatics and emotions of these characters...or how the BIG reveal was poorly written. I understand it is a kid's book and did make sense to me when I read it 12 years ago.

Based on my memories I still don't think Sol was a villain and found everything involving him to be underwhelming. The fandom has many speculations about Sol and if he will return but I doubt it...he appears and disappears like a fart in the wind. The real villain of the story is the secret of the three parentages, which was pretty obvious as soon as they revealed that the kits just showed up with Squirrelflight and Leafpool...the ignorance of the clan to what had really happened just doesn't make sense, it makes even less sense then when Bluestar "lost" her kits to a fox and they show up as apprentices with the same names, six moons later at the gathering and no one bats an eye.

I had issues with Hollyleaf the whole book, she was so torn up by what happened with her parents that she had to reveal it in front of every cat in the forest..thinking it would be a good idea despite the fact that she was perfectly ok with murdering a clanmate and lying to everyone about it. This cat went from 0 to 100 and it made no sense...this could have been written better but again, it's a kids book so I cant be that upset.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

this my headline

it was so Obviously thet leafpool was actually there mother
like Seriously they couldn't have made it more obvious I mean jayfeather
even had a similar voice to Crowfeather whan he was younger and a Stubborn attitude lol

Kinda annoying voices

The narrator has a lot of passion while reading but Jayfeathers voice is ear bleeding to listen to while wearing head phones! Also Graystripes voice is really goofy sounding. The acting was really good though, the climax of the book made me tear up a bit with the pain in everyone’s voice. If you really like warriors give the audiobooks a try but it isn’t a game changer on how you consume the series.

good

good book dnjddj djemd jewelry ejjejdd dmdmmd djdjdmdmd djdmd did did jdjdj ddjdjjd djdjjd decided

I love it But...

I will miss Holly leaf and honeyfern so much!😫 but overall a good story 😸

Macleod Andrews is the best

Macleod Andrews gives all the characters voices and keeps up with them so they change with their age and with all the other perspectives he keeps track of all these characters and reads the story beautifully