Story mirrors our life -- to a point -- spoilers

My transgender daughter transitioned between first grade and kindergarten, just like Claude/Poppy in this book. I couldn't believe someone had written a story about a situation like ours -- although we know many families with trans kids, I had never read a work of fiction like this. So, to Laurie Frankel, thank you.

The book rang true on many, many levels. The effects of the transition on siblings, the struggle with secrecy. But in some ways, it was different from our story. For example, my child never said she "wanted" to be a girl. She was adamant from as soon as she could talk that she "is" a girl. "I is a girl, mama." Laurie Frankel hit the nail on the head with the depression and the trepidation of the parents.

That's where our stories diverge. My child is 100% a girl. But this book portrays a child who is a little more on the gender spectrum. That is, not 100% girl or 100% boy. Somewhere in the middle. I find that a great number of the kids we've come to know are on that spectrum. So kudos for shedding a light on those who don't fit into a bucket.

The characters rang true, and I was on the edge of my seat trying to figure out what they would do. The Thailand part is a little far-fetched, although also educational.

Thank you again, Laurie Frankel, for legitimizing (but not sensationalizing) the world of those who do not quite/yet fit with society's norms.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

167 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

I liked this novel about a non-traditional family

This novel is a about a family with four boys, with the mother a doctor and the father a writer/poet. The fifth child is also a boy, but at age three, Claude just wants to wear dresses. This novel spans Claude / Poppy's life from age 3 to 10, as the child and parents struggle with issues of gender identity. I was a little hesitant about this when I noticed most reviewers seemed to be female. I am a male father of three sons, and a teacher who teaches transgender kids. There was a lot attracting me to this novel. The start of the book felt more like a chick lit romance, and I almost stopped. I am glad that I continued, though. This book and family slowly grew on me, and was filled with many painful and touching moments. This also had flaws. For one thing, I felt like the characters were fictional. They never transformed into the real people who come alive in great novels. Nevertheless, I still cared about them and about the situations I found them in. The "fairy tale" thread, especially at the end, seemed over the top to me. Still, as a whole, I was entertained and drawn in by this family story, and I feel I better understand the issues of transgender children. The story mostly stopped short of being too preachy.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

81 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

No, Ms. Frankel, this is NOT how it always is

What disappointed you about This Is How It Always Is?

As a parent of a transgender child (though with differing circumstances to that of the family in the book), I really wanted to like this book, but the more I listened, the more the story and characters felt increasingly inauthentic and stereotypical, building to an ending that felt truncated, simplistic, and clichéd.

What was most disappointing about Laurie Frankel’s story?

The inauthenticity of the characters. (Warning: there are spoilers ahead.) The physician mother, Rosie, acted completely out of character for someone of her education and disposition, displaying an unbelievable lack of knowledge and nuance concerning her child's transgender issues. Had the story been set 25 years earlier, this might have been a little more understandable, but any modern medical professional today would not be so ignorant. I was also very disappointed in Rosie's reaction to facing her trans child Poppy's issues...in two distinct points in the plot, she literally runs away from their problems rather than facing them, and the second time, when she and Poppy flee Seattle to Thailand following the child's traumatic outing at school, Rosie basically becomes one of the world's worst parents, endangering Poppy's life by taking her to a remote jungle, spending almost no time with Poppy while they are there, and completely abandoning her husband and other four children. This occurs about 3/4 of the way through the novel, and I really struggled to finish it after being so annoyed by this abrupt turn in the plot.

I should have stopped at that point, because the ending was a disaster, where fleeing mother and daughter return to Seattle to reunite with their family as if nothing had happened, and culminating in Poppy only days after returning home attending a middle school dance where the meanest of the bullies who drove her away asks her to dance. I could not help rolling my eyes and facepalming after such a such a ham-fisted and abrupt tying up of loose ends.

Which character – as performed by Gabra Zackman – was your favorite?

Poppy's father, Penn, was probably my favorite...he seemed the most reasonable and fleshed out character, though the parallel fairy tale he tells the children throughout the story reflecting Poppy's journey grew a bit tiresome by the end.

What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?

Disappointment, mostly. There was a great opportunity here to really explore the lives of families with a trans child, and it really missed the mark. Perhaps most disappointing was the treatment of Poppy herself. Throughout most of the story, she was treated more like what is called a McGuffin in film, a largely irrelevant plot device used to steer the story, rather than as a real character with heart and motivation. This improved somewhat as the novel progressed, but by this time the narrative had gone so far off the rails that it was lost.

Any additional comments?

This novel felt very poorly researched to me. The acts of discrimination perpetrated against Poppy and her family were massively exaggerated, particularly those from younger characters. My child is transitioning in as conservative and bible-banging of a midwestern small town as you could find in the U.S., and the reaction from most people--but especially peers--has been overwhelmingly accepting and supportive. Ms. Frankel treats Madison, Wisconsin, like it's an epicenter of hate and intolerance, and that is simply not accurate. She also has characters who are professionals advising the parents with very bad advice, particularly keeping Poppy's transition secret from almost everyone after they move to Seattle. This is not how it always is...not at all...and this book gives a soap opera treatment to a topic that deserves better.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

46 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Beautiful story. Beautiful performance.

This book has enlightened me and given me courage to stand firm in what I know to be the most important thing I can do in the face of "different," show love. Be love.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

40 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Change is hard, especially if it's your child

This Is How It Always Is is a novel about a transgender child, Claude/Poppy, born into a large and loving family, how that family comes to accept that Claude wants to be a girl when he grows up, what they do to help that happen, the missteps they make, and secrets they try to keep.

"This is how it always is. You have to make these huge decisions on behalf of your kid, this tiny human whose fate and future is entirely in your hands, who trusts you to know what’s good and right and then to be able to make it happen. If…you make the wrong call, well, nothing less than your child’s entire future and happiness is at stake."

I'm not sure your child's entire future and happiness is at stake with parental wrong calls (at least I hope not), but parenting is full of tough calls, and dealing with transgender issues must be one of the toughest. That's part of what makes writing this book so brave; it's a reality for Laurie Frankel.

Frankel has made it clear in interviews that this book isn't specifically about her daughter, but it does present in fictional form issues and feelings that parents of a gender dysphoric child may have to deal with. I wish this novel had been slightly less preachy, and there is a therapist character that I'm not sure provided any useful therapy, but I enjoyed reading This Is How It Always Is mainly because it made me think and delve further. Is gender dysphoria a sort of spectrum, ranging from people who simply enjoy dressing in clothes of the opposite sex, to people who truly want to be the opposite sex? I don't know, nor am I sure there are really answers to that question, but this novel made me want to find out more, and also hope that I've been an accepting, loving, and protective parent myself.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

36 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Great.. for the most part..

I loved the beginning of this book. The character development. The story felt current and plausible. In fact, I enjoyed all of the book until the last hour or so.
I thought the Thailand trip was a bit ridiculous and it felt like a super rushed way to END the book. How I wish it had a better ending. I wish she had dug in, like she did with the rest of the book. Tying up all the ends seems like a short cut and I finished feeling mostly dissatisfied.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

31 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Didn't think I would like it but loved it instead!

Magical and eye opening and should be mandatory reading for the whole hunan race. I especially liked the story within the story.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

28 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Great story but poor choice of narrator

I almost returned this book because the narrator was so bad. She constantly mumbles and whispers and really takes away from the feeling and emotion of the book. I’m glad I suffered through it because it’s a wonderful story and so eloquently written.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

20 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Amazing story

I listen to a lot of books and this narration and story are so amazing. Very enjoyable and worth your time!

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

18 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

This is a great book

Very timely now that the Trump administration plans to roll back protections for transgender kids in schools by allowing individual states to decide which bathroom these kids have to use. Hopefully readers will become more educated about this vulnerable population.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.

17 les gens ont trouvé cela utile