Dreadful narrator

The narrator, Jilly Bond, is dreadful. Doesn't anyone at the publisher or Audible review these recordings?

10 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

So Disappointed!

This is one of my favorite Mary Stewart books and I couldn’t wait for an unabridged audio version to be released. The narrator really bothered me! I found I got somewhat used to her voice for Gaelis by telling myself “this is an old lady retelling her love story,” but I cringed every time William or Christopher John spoke.

6 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

A bewitching tale from the masterful pen of Mary Stewart

Thornyhold has long been one of my favorite books since I discovered it as a teenager in our tiny country library. Brimming with Lady Stewart’s light magic, lush imagery, and signature wit, and with just a hint of mystery, Thornyhold tells the story of a lonely young woman and the magical and idyllic house and gardens left to her by her good-witch-godmother, a Mary Poppins sort, and the healing the house brings to everyone who loves it—humans and animals alike. A short, delicious story with a witchy-wise-woman atmosphere that I savor every autumn. So grateful audible released this new version as the previous one was severely abridged and had poor audio quality. The narrator did a lovely job overall; I enjoyed her regular voice as she read the novel which is in first person, but I didn’t particularly love the voice she used for the heroine. Since the novel was in first person, I wish she had just stuck with the main voice she used. But it didn’t bother me enough to return it, and I’ll certainly listen to it many more times.

3 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Narrator is awful

Looked forward to this book, but the narrator is awful, and truth be told, the story isn't as good as I remember. In 25 years I think my taste has changed a great deal. I have requested they add Victoria Holt THE INDIA FAN, and if they do, I hope the narrator does it justice

7 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Thornyhold

One of my favorite Mary Stewart novels. I thought the reader was very good. I almost didn't buy this because of the negative reviews about the reader. I am so glad I did. A lovely story!

2 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

My favorite Mary Stewart so far

It’s a bit slow on the romance at the start, but I didn’t mind that. I loved Gilly and her aunt and all the little features of her life. She’s such a kindhearted and intelligent heroine and Jilly Bond brings her to life so well. This is a wonderfully cozy read. Recommended for winter nights or summer afternoons... or anytime you want a comforting friend.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Entertaining

This story is told by a grandmother looking back on her earlier years. She was an unhappy child who grew into a confident, wise woman in later life with the help of an eccentric aunt. All the Stewart familiars are there, lonely children, animals in need, and historic context with supernatural implications. I liked the book which dealt more with the characters’ psychological and personal motivations and insights rather than overly sensual romance. It is a kind of coming of age and personal growth story which made it a little deeper than her usual story. I thought the narrator’s voice was appropriate for the story which is told about events that happened many years prior. She had a nice tone which was easy to listen to for me. I did not like her voice of the male love interest, but he does not say much so it was not much of a distraction. The rest of her voices seemed fine to me. I combined reading and listening to the book and heard some parts twice. It is a book I may pick up again in the future either to listen or to read.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

NOT Mary Stewart's best

I stuck it out to the end, because I hate to leave any story unfinished. However, this book was a big disappointment. It was slow, and much of it dreary. I didn't care for the narration. The characters were pretty interesting. If I had known what I know now, I would have bought the abridged version narrated by Jenny Agutter.

1 personne a trouvé cela utile

Childhood Favorite Relived!

Although it was not this particular recording Thornyhold was the first Audiobook I listened to with my mother as a child and has always been one of my favorites! It took me a little while to get used to the reader, but once I did I felt she was absolutely perfect! It is a beautiful story and very calming to listen to. I have found myself also having somewhat enchanted dreams as I've been listening to it. A+++ Highly recommended!

Great Storytelling!

Nothing better for a cozy listen than a Mary Stewart mystery. Always worth the time.