On this episode of Movie Joust!, we take on Avatar : Fire and Ash— James Cameron’s latest swing at epic blockbuster filmmaking — and ask the uncomfortable question: does this franchise still earn the awe it demands, or is the spectacle finally outpacing the substance?

We break down our sharply divided reactions, from the film’s overwhelming visual ambition to its emotional sincerity, narrative sprawl, and cultural relevance. Is Cameron still pushing the medium forward, or are audiences being asked to mistake scale for depth?

As always, we debate the hype, challenge the consensus, and figure out who this movie is actually for — die-hard fans, casual viewers, or no one at all.

This week, the guys discuss whether Chloe Zhao's film 'Hamnet' lives up to the award season hype, and whether its buzzy performances from Jessie Buckley and Paul Mescal will take home Oscar gold!

Than, it's the return of James L. Brooks with 'Ella McCay,' but has this once great filmmaker delivered the worst movie of the year?

Jason, Josh, and Jesse break down the Atlanta Film Critics Circle's list of the best movies of 2025, including favorite performances, epic stunts, and underrated gems! Plus, look out for the guys' own picks for what movies to catch up on from the last 12 months.