Alleged Inuit village where everyone mysteriously disappeared in 1930.

In this gripping episode of Murder Before Myths, host Casey dives into a haunting cold case from her own hometown—one that went unsolved for decades until a breakthrough in DNA technology brought long-awaited justice. What seemed lost to time is now a chilling reminder that the past never truly stays buried.

Meanwhile, Quenten takes us down a darker, more legendary path as he explores the terrifying tale of the Jersey Devil. Is it just a myth born from fear—or could something truly monstrous be lurking in the Pine Barrens?

True crime meets folklore in a twisted double-feature you won’t want to miss.

I

n this haunting episode of Murder Before Myths, Casey takes a deep look into the tragic 1988 murder of Gordon Church—a horrific hate crime that shook the nation and, years later, found justice through advancements in DNA evidence. It's a powerful story of loss, resilience, and long-overdue accountability.

Then, Quenten explores the chilling legend of Angikuni Lake, where an entire Inuit village is said to have mysteriously vanished without a trace. Is it folklore, government cover-up, or something far more sinister?

Two chilling stories—one rooted in fact, the other steeped in mystery.

In this chilling episode of Murder Before Myths, we explore two tales that blur the line between brutal reality and eerie folklore.

🧼 First, we uncover the twisted true crime of Leonarda Cianciulli, the infamous Soap-Maker of Correggio. A mother obsessed with fate, human sacrifice, and dark rituals, she lured victims to their doom—melting their remains into soap and teacakes. But was she a cold-blooded killer, or driven by something darker than madness?

🕯️ Then, we head to the frozen reaches of Iceland, where folklore tells of The Nameless Shadow — a faceless entity that steals your shadow when you harbor guilt. Those marked by it fade from mirrors, from memory… and from existence itself.

Two disturbing stories. One grounded in murder. The other whispered through myth.
You decide which one keeps you up at night.

Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at letstelltheirstory@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/letstelltheirstory/Spotify: telltheirstoryTwitter: @LetstheirstoryFacebook: https://rb.gy/l1trsPatreon: patreon.com/letstelltheirstoryDiscord: https://discord.gg/vAs8JSRY6M

Thank you for joining Let's Tell Their Story, where I tell a story of a true crime case that has gone cold. When I go through the case with the research that I have done, the facts given are thoughtful and truefully to the best of my knowledge. If you have any case I should do email me at letstelltheirstory@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/letstelltheirstory/Spotify: telltheirstoryTwitter: @LetstheirstoryFacebook: https://rb.gy/l1trsPatreon: patreon.com/letstelltheirstoryDiscord: https://discord.gg/vAs8JSRY6M

We’re diving into the twisted story of Thomas William Randolph, a man with more than just skeletons in his closet… and then we’re switching gears (hard) to talk about Cuba’s wild problem with cocaine hippos—yes, really.

It's dark, it's weird, it's wild... just how we like it.

In this video, we delve into two enigmatic stories that have captivated audiences:

Part 1: The Enigma of Tiffany and the Mysterious Man
Unravel the perplexing tale of Tiffany and her association with a shadowy figure. What secrets lie beneath their story? Join us as we piece together the clues and explore the depths of this mystery.​

Part 2: The Urban Legend of the Hippo and the Dwarf
Discover the bizarre urban legend that claims a circus dwarf was accidentally swallowed by a yawning hippopotamus during a performance. This tale, originating in the late 1980s, has been widely circulated and even mistaken for real news by reputable outlets. We'll examine the origins of this hoax and its impact on popular culture.