The Dallas Cowboys defense didn’t just “regress” this season — it collapsed. And there are real, uncomfortable reasons why.
In this episode, I break down four hard truths about what went wrong on the defensive side of the ball — starting with the obvious: losing Micah Parsons mattered. A player who wins that fast and that often at the line of scrimmage changes everything. Whether he’s worth $47M per year is a debate for front offices (and yes, the Green Bay Packers clearly thought so), but pretending his departure didn’t hurt this defense is pure denial.
Next, we get into Matt Eberflus’ struggles in Dallas. He’s been a good defensive coordinator before, and his concepts work elsewhere — but with this roster, he didn’t have answers. No real adjustments. No backup plan. And that showed week after week.
Then comes the roster construction. Jerry, Stephen, and Will McClay put together a defensive group that simply didn’t have enough talent — forcing Eberflus to lean on young, limited, or miscast players in major roles. When you lose cornerstone veterans and ask late-round picks and backups to survive on islands, the results are predictable.
Finally, I explain why the next defensive coordinator hire matters more than ever. This annual coordinator carousel doesn’t work when the roster isn’t ready and the scheme doesn’t fit. The Cowboys need to hire someone they believe in — not just a familiar name — and align the scheme, philosophy, and personnel from the ground up.
If you’re wondering why this defense fell apart, what actually matters moving forward, and how the Cowboys can stop repeating the same mistakes, this episode lays it all out.
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy