Episode 41 Brian Shaffer · Part I — “Vanished in Plain Sight”

The tape rolls, the escalator hums, and a doorway becomes a stage where nothing happens and everything changes. In Part I, we stay inside the hours before the disappearance—dinner with his father, a bar-hop back to the Ugly Tuna, a quick call to Alexis, and the camera frame at 1:55 a.m. that swallows a six-foot-two med student three weeks after the death of his mother, Renee. We rebuild the minute-by-minute timeline, walk the under-construction service corridor the cameras barely touched, and follow the first 72 hours as Columbus searched rooftops, dumpsters, riverbanks, and storm drains. Along the way, we translate what 2006 technology could (and couldn’t) do: analog PTZ lenses, looping tapes, and a nine-second blind sweep that turned into a nineteen-year question. No theories yet—just the night itself, the search that followed, and the stubborn gap between what the footage shows and what the evidence should have left behind.

#TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #CreepyStories #Vanished #MidnightMysteryArchive #MissingPerson #unsolved #coldcasefiles #unsolvedcase #creepystories #brianshaffer #columbus #Ohio

Episode 40- Johnny Gosch · Part IV — “Aftermath, Advocacy, and the Echoes Still Heard”

Noreen’s living-room walls are lined with boxes now—press clippings turned amber, government letters, and the dog-eared notebooks she once carried into every interview. In Part IV we sit with the aftermath. We trace how one family’s search grew into a national crusade: milk-carton photos, the first AMBER-style alerts, and the “Johnny Gosch Bill” that re-wired how police log a missing child. We unpack the victories that stuck, the reforms that stalled, and the personal toll of steering a movement while the central question—where is Johnny?—remained unanswered. Then we widen the lens: what today’s advocates still borrow from Noreen’s playbook, how social media both amplifies and distorts a case, and why investigators keep an open file more than forty years on. No neat endings here—just the resonance of one disappearance reshaping the very idea of “missing” in America, and the quiet hope that the next call might finally close the circle.

#TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #CreepyStories #Vanished #MidnightMysteryArchive #MissingPerson #unsolved #coldcasefiles #unsolvedcase #creepystories #johnnygosch #humantrafficking #thefranklinscandal #desMoines #Iowa

Episode 39- Johnny Gosch · Part III — “Networks, Narratives, and the Open File”

The map on the wall is crowded: arrows, names, and theories that try to connect Johnny’s disappearance to something bigger. In Part III, we step through those rooms one by one—the organized-ring narrative, claims of institutional cover-up, links proposed to other Des Moines cases, and the photographs and papers that seemed to promise certainty—and ask what survives contact with the record. Along the way, we translate how cold-case work actually moves today: rebuilding the corner-minute timeline, “vehicle archaeology,” careful re-interviews, digitizing old lead cards, and what would genuinely shift the case’s posture now. No appeals, no shortcuts—just the difference between stories that explain and evidence that endures.

#TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #CreepyStories #Vanished #MidnightMysteryArchive #MissingPerson #unsolved #coldcasefiles #unsolvedcase #creepystories #johnnygosch #humantrafficking #thefranklinscandal #desMoines #Iowa

Episode 380 Johnny Gosch · Part II — “Photos, Affidavits & a Story That Grew”

The morning at the corner never answered the central question—so the case grew. In Part II, we follow Johnny’s file as it leaves West Des Moines and enters a national spotlight. We examine the photographs that ignited debate—where they surfaced, how analysts tried to date and contextualize them, and what a still image can and cannot prove. We unpack sworn statements and affidavits, including how investigators separate method from authorship and why civil outcomes aren’t criminal proof. We also cover the alleged late-night visit recounted by Johnny’s mother and the law-enforcement posture that kept it in the realm of claim rather than evidence. Throughout, we draw a bright line between record and allegation, ending with what still stands under weight after decades of attention.

#TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #CreepyStories #Vanished #MidnightMysteryArchive #MissingPerson #unsolved #coldcasefiles #unsolvedcase #creepystories #johnnygosch #humantrafficking #thefranklinscandal #desMoines #Iowa

Episode 37, Johnny Gosch · Part I —

West Des Moines, Iowa—September 5, 1982. Twelve-year-old paperboy Johnny Gosch heads out before dawn for his Sunday route—a morning that, for the first time, he’s running alone. At the bundle drop, other carriers fold and band papers as a car idles, loops back, and a man asks for directions through a passenger window. Minutes later, Johnny’s wagon and undelivered papers are found near the corner—without Johnny. This opening chapter reconstructs the morning step by step: the route choreography, the change in routine, Noreen’s first call to police, and the measured early response roughly forty-five minutes later. We unpack how that tempo set the stage for an immediate split between the family and West Des Moines PD leadership, then lay out the overlapping eyewitness accounts from paperboys and neighbors that anchor the timeline. Finally, we pare the day down to what can be said with certainty—what’s fixed, what isn’t, and why the silence at the corner still matters.

#TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #CreepyStories #Vanished #MidnightMysteryArchive #MissingPerson #unsolved #coldcasefiles #unsolvedcase #creepystories #johnnygosch #humantrafficking #thefranklinscandal #desMoines #Iowa

Episode 36-The Disappearance of Genette Tate

19 August 1978, Aylesbeare, Devon. Thirteen-year-old papergirl Genette Tate rounds a bend on Within Lane—and vanishes. Minutes later, two friends find her blue Dawes bicycle on its side, the front wheel still spinning and newspapers scattered across the tarmac. No shout, no tire marks, no witnesses.

In this investigation, The Midnight Mystery Archive reconstructs the timeline minute by minute, follows the massive search that scoured hedgerows, ponds and quarries, and explains why detectives came to believe Genette was taken rapidly into a vehicle. We unpack the decades-long inquiry, the cold-case overhaul known as Operation Lester, and the circumstantial case that made delivery driver Robert Black the prime suspect—right up until his death halted a decision on prosecution. Along the way, we examine what 1970s forensics couldn’t do, what modern science might still reveal, and how one lane became a memorial to a girl who never came home.

If you were on the A3052 that afternoon, worked on PD&S vans, or remember a vehicle parked oddly on Within Lane, police still want to hear from you.

#TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #CreepyStories #Vanished #MidnightMysteryArchive #MissingPerson #unsolved #coldcasefiles #unsolvedcase #creepystories #UKUnsolved #GenetteTate #UKMissing #UK #UnitedKingdom

Episode 35-Lucille Butterworth

25 August 1969, Claremont, Tasmania. At 5:55 p.m. radio copy-writer and beauty-pageant finalist Lucille Butterworth waited for the city bus outside the Shalimar Hostel. Ten minutes later the shelter was empty, her evening gown never reached rehearsal, and the turquoise Holden sedan seen cruising Main Road faded into legend.

This episode retraces Lucille’s last confirmed movements, the frantic 1969 search, and the men who fell under suspicion—convicted sex-offender Geoffrey Charles Hunt and serial rapist John William Wakefield—yet were never charged. We unpack the limits of pre-DNA forensics, the 2015-16 coronial inquest that named Hunt as the probable killer, and the 2019 jailhouse confession that still wasn’t enough for prosecutors.

Fifty-five years on, Lucille’s family still searches the Derwent’s banks while investigators wait for a single piece of evidence—one that may still lie along the Lyell Highway, or in a memory that’s finally ready to be spoken.

#TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #CreepyStories #Vanished #MidnightMysteryArchive #MissingPerson #unsolved #coldcasefiles #unsolvedcase #creepystories #Australia

Episode 34-Laureen Rahn

Spring 1980, Manchester, New Hampshire: Fourteen-year-old Laureen Rahn vanished from a third-floor apartment on Merrimack Street. When her mother returned after midnight, every hallway bulb on all three floors had been unscrewed, the front door was unlocked, and the back door stood open. A friend was asleep in Laureen’s bed. Laureen was gone—her new sneakers and clothes left behind.

This episode of The Midnight Mystery Archive reconstructs the last verified movements inside the apartment, the early investigation, and the details that continue to unsettle: a year of silent 3:45 a.m. phone calls, California long-distance calls billed to the home (two motels and a teen hotline), and unconfirmed sightings that led nowhere. We explore why police moved off the initial “runaway” label, how 1980-era phone tech could route distant calls to Judith Rahn’s bill, and why the unscrewed bulbs matter as more than a piece of lore.

Carefully separating proven facts from rumor, we also place the case in its neighborhood context—another disappearance six weeks later just blocks away (no proven connection)—and close with practical steps that could still help today. Forty-plus years on, the questions remain simple and unforgiving: who darkened the hall, who opened the doors, and who spoke through all that silence?

#TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #LaureenRahn #CreepyStories #Vanished #MidnightMysteryArchive #MissingPerson #unsolved #coldcasefiles #unsolvedcase #creepystories