What if I told you you’re struggling in sales because you’ve been approaching it the wrong way? In this episode of the Sell by Being Human podcast, Alex Smith sits down with sales coach and entrepreneur Natasha Hemmingway to flip the script on everything you think you know about selling. Her message is simple but powerful. Sales is serving. And hustle? It might actually be pushing your dream clients away.

Natasha shares how growing up with a servant leader mom shaped her philosophy of heart over hustle, and why mindset, not strategy, is usually what holds entrepreneurs back. They unpack fear of rejection, fear of pricing too high, burnout, and the sneaky subconscious patterns that sabotage growth.

You’ll also hear her practical fear-to-faith framework, why most entrepreneurs are undercharging, and how being crystal clear in conversations builds trust fast.

If you want to grow your business without feeling pushy, awkward, or salesy, this conversation will change how you show up and how you close.

Key Takeaways

1. Why hustle energy can secretly sabotage your sales
2. The “Fear to Faith” cycle that breaks limiting beliefs
3. How your subconscious affects pricing, confidence, and closing
4. Why most entrepreneurs are undercharging
5. The truth about “not all money being good money”
6. How to qualify clients with clarity and integrity
7. Why connection always beats persuasion

In This Episode:

1. [00:00] Introduction & guest welcome
2. [01:04] Personal connection & authenticity in sales
3. [03:17] Natasha’s take on Sell by Being Human
4. [05:06] Mindset and self-relationship in sales
5. [06:14] Role models: Servant leadership & early influences
6. [09:14] Sales beyond traditional roles
7. [11:01] Defining hustle (and why it backfires)
8. [13:31] Balancing hustle and heart: Client challenges
9. [14:35] Strategy vs. mindset in sales success
10. [18:38] Practicing what you preach: Natasha’s own journey
11. [19:41] Faith, surrender, and decision-making
12. [21:13] Qualifying clients & setting boundaries
13. [22:03] Authenticity and invitation in sales calls
14. [26:13] Sales as a universal skill
15. [27:12] Sales in family & daily life
16. [29:43] Mindset, fear, and the subconscious
17. [30:20] Breaking through fear: The fear-to-faith cycle
18. [36:13] Pricing, value, and worth in sales
19. [38:06] What makes Natasha... Natasha
20. [40:10] Family support & self-care
21. [42:02] Where to find Natasha
22. [42:19] Closing & gratitude

Notable Quotes

1. [01:49] "At the end of the day, we aren't what we do; we are who we are" — Natasha
2. [03:24] “Selling with heart, not hustle, is selling by being human." — Natasha
3. [03:48] "I always say sales equals serving; you are serving a person." — Natasha
4. [12:01] "Hustle can lead to burnout, and hustle can actually push people away from you." — Natasha
5. [34:12] "If you don’t ask, you don’t know, and if somebody says no, what do you lose? Nothing." — Natasha
6. [36:36] "General rule of thumb for most entrepreneurs: you are not charging enough. Period." — Natasha
7. [39:09] “No matter the time or day, I’m always going to be there; I show up for people.” — Natasha

Our Guest

Natasha Hemmingway is a sales coach, consultant, and pricing profitability expert helping entrepreneurs and corporate sales teams grow revenue without sacrificing authenticity. Her philosophy Heart, Not Hustle empowers professionals to sell with integrity, confidence, and sustainable strategy.