What if the thing we struggle with most as writers… is exactly what editors struggle with too?
In this episode, I am joined by Phoebe Morgan, Executive Publisher for Commercial Fiction at Simon & Schuster UK and bestselling author of five novels. We talk openly about everything from hook-driven fiction to the reality of acquisitions, the trends dominating the industry right now, and what it really feels like to write your own books while editing others for a living.
Along the way, I also answer your brilliant questions from how to navigate genres to building a vivid sense of place and we hear from fellow tortured writers about cats on keyboards, chronic rabbit-hole researching, and writer’s block that feels more like “writer’s constipation.”
What We Explore
- The Truth About Being an Editor-Writer: I ask Phoebe how she balances editing bestselling commercial fiction with writing her own novels and whether she can ever truly switch off that editorial brain.
- What Editors Actually Look For: We break down hooks, voice, market trends, and why some genres catch fire while others require a big marketing push to find readers.
- Separating Drafting From Editing: Phoebe shares why she writes fast first drafts, why she doesn’t take her own writing too seriously, and how she handles edits she doesn’t agree with.
- Industry Transparency & The Honest Editor: We talk about why she launched her brilliant Substack and how demystifying acquisitions, sales meetings and publishing decisions helps writers feel less alone.
And of course… Bookaholic Bex is back with another gorgeous recommendation - this time a children’s novel perfect for adults too.
Every time I speak to someone like Phoebe, I’m reminded that even the most experienced editors and bestselling authors wrestle with the same doubts, drafts and dilemmas we all do. If you’re feeling tortured this week, trust me - you are in excellent company.
The Tortured Writers Podcast is sponsored by Cheshire Novel Prize, an international writing competition for debut writers where every entry gets feedback. Go to cheshirenovelprize.com for more details or follow on Instagram @cheshirenovelprize.
The Tortured Writers Podcast is produced by Urban Podcasts.