Send us a text

A quiet click in a digital archive set off a bigger question: how did a tidy tale about the “Great Western Trail” in 1873 outrun the dusty, documented truth of 1874? We follow the breadcrumb trail from a glossy magazine headline to the rail-choked streets of Dodge City, where buffalo hides, not longhorns, drove the economy. From there, we trace John T. Lytle’s government contract to feed the Sioux, the mapped river crossings, and the August 1, 1874 deadline that defined the first verified drive.

Along the way, we meet J. Frank Dobie—ranch-born, campus-bound, and unapologetically devoted to story over footnote. Dobie prized living voices more than ledgers, and he found a perfect partner in Frank Collinson, an Englishman turned cowboy who wrote his memories decades after the fact. Collinson likely helped gather cattle in late 1873 and later fused that groundwork with the 1874 trailblazing into one clean narrative. It’s a classic compression: a roundup becomes a “first drive,” and a modern brand name—“Great Western Trail”—is retrofitted to the past until it feels original.

We don’t stop at debunking. We explore why these stories endure, how civic branding amplified a legend, and what’s at stake when heritage tourism, folklore, and archival history collide. The lesson isn’t to toss out the campfire tale. It’s to read it alongside the map: let the archive keep the dates straight while the storytellers keep the culture alive. By the end, you’ll see how a name, a narrative, and a single year can redirect the memory of the West—and why holding fact and fable in tension gives us a richer, more honest past.

If this journey changed how you think about Western history, follow the show, leave a review, and share it with a friend who loves a good trail story.

Support the show

If you'd like to buy one or more of our fully illustrated dime novel publications, you can click the link I've included.