Dark and compelling - Gillian Flynn readalike

This is the kind of suspenseful, tension building story that I'm hoping for every time I open a book labeled "Thriller." Very reminiscent of Gillian Flynn, Tessa's story was dark without ever getting into the details of what actually took place that caused her to end up in a grave with other murdered girls with no memory of how or why she was there. The tension in the story builds as Tessa tries to piece together what happened as the time ticks down for the possibly innocent man on death row who was found guilty of the crime that haunts her life. I was so eager to get this audiobook and I wasn't disappointed. The narration was fantastic, from the southern drawl of a friend, to teenager whine, to the whimsical neighbor, the narrator breathed life into each character.

The writing itself was vivid and descriptive which helped give each character nuance and depth that was enhanced by the exceptional narration. It was one of those books that kept me up all night reading because I couldn't sleep until I had the answers I needed.

The reason I didn't give this a full 5 stars is because of several things - First, the way the story weaves back and forth between past and present was sometimes jarring and confusing and at times made it a bit hard to follow. This often made it difficult for me to simply lose myself in the narration and in the story the way I would have liked. Then, while I enjoyed the diversions and false trails that kept me guessing, when all was finally revealed, it struck me as a little too far-fetched to seem plausible AND there were too many things left unanswered.

While I wanted more from the story, it was because the story and the characters were so compelling. I wanted to understand more about the intriguing friendship between Tessa and Lydia, I wanted to hear more about Tessa's strange and quirky grandfather and his creepy house, I wanted to learn more about Terrell and his experience on death row, I wanted to learn more about the other "Susan" victims. But even though I still wanted more - I still loved the story. It's actually because I so thoroughly enjoyed it that I wanted more from it!

I need to find more audiobooks like this so I'm going to check out more of this author's work.

160 people found this helpful

Slow and predictable

For a book billed as "A Novel of Suspense", Black-Eyed Susans is oddly lacking in suspense. Stylistically, the writing is quite good but the novel isn't particularly exciting or suspenseful. Instead, it's a character study that attempts to build slowly to it's final revelations which, unfortunately, are far too predictable.

The narration was good enough to get me through this one but I can't recommend it.

36 people found this helpful

Fantastically interesting... as long as you know

I am thankful to the reviewer who mentioned that the book did a lot of time hopping back and forth.,and since I went into it knowing that it was one of the BEST suspense novels I have listened to in a very long time! Everything from the story line, to the interesting details, to the narration was fantastic

136 people found this helpful

Not in the right mood

I mostly enjoyed this story, although I don’t think it was right for my mood. I just didn’t have the patience to let the book lead me along.

It was told in two time lines: One was Young Tessie’ POV just before the trial, the other was Today’s Tessa just before the execution. The story of what happened - is the killer guilty, whatever happened to Lydia etc, is slowly revealed between the two narratives but instead of being pulled in by the mystery and all the suspense, it just got on my nerves. JUST TELL ME ALREADY!

As a consequence of my impatience, I didn’t get properly sucked into the book and so by the time it got to the twist-ending, I just rolled my eyes as opposed to letting my jaw drop.

Too bad for me, I think I may have missed out on the best part of the ride.

45 people found this helpful

Too weird for me....

Strange story, unevenly written. Maybe once an hour I considered cutting my losses and quitting, but then some little thing would catch my attention, and I'd soldier on for awhile more. Maybe I just didn't like the mixed genre -- it can't quite decide if it's a straight-out novel, a coming of age story, a crime chronicle or a legal thriller with death penalty pretensions. It's funny that the reviews call it "suspense". I suppose any kind of a book can be called "suspense" -- if we readers weren't waiting for something to happen, wondering what it would be, would we keep reading any of them?

Anyway, not for me. I'll steer clear of this author in the future. Good narrator, though. Did a good job with lots of different voices, accents.

64 people found this helpful

Great Book! Not difficult to follow at all!!

I kept hemming and hawing about getting this book because of other reviewers mentioning it was difficult to follow with the back and forth in time. Yes, it does go back and forth but is very easy to follow. The story is unique and the performance outstanding! So, take a leap of faith, if you like suspense, you won't be disappointed!

68 people found this helpful

Couldn't stop listening!

If you're a fan of Gillian Flynn, Kimberly Mccreight, or similar authors with that same ability to pull you in in and weave a story from slowly revealed bits and pieces, you might enjoy this book.

I was hesitant to get this book. In fact, it has been sitting in my wish list for a long time. I finally spent the credit when I had very few options left and was looking for a worthwhile mystery. Once I I started listening I was totally hooked..

Some other reviewers have mentioned that they found it jarring how the book moves back-and-forth in time. I did not find it difficult at all and had no problem following the story.

All that being said, this is not a perfect book. There are some areas that could've been better much developed and the ending did seem a bit rushed.

However, it was still a great listen and I enjoyed it. I definitely think it was worth my credit.

The narration was very well done.

25 people found this helpful

Helped me sleep

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

If you need a good night sleep turn this on and you will sleep like never before:)

Has Black-Eyed Susans turned you off from other books in this genre?

No I would say not. I will just be more careful in the future, as all reviews can be misleading.

How could the performance have been better?

A better story perhaps?

Do you think Black-Eyed Susans needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

No because the first wasn't worth my ear space,

Any additional comments?

Not a mystery just a very hypervigilant mother with major past issues. Not my cup of tea.

10 people found this helpful

Oddly Entertaining!

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

Yes I would but with the recommendation, I would tell them that they have to give the book a chance to get going. It starts out kind of odd. But once it gets going, it's really good!

What did you like best about this story?

I really like this author. Very similar to Gillian Flynn. Excellent character development, plot, and twists.

Which scene was your favorite?

The descriptions are vivid. I could see in my minds eye exactly what was going on in the scenes. It was just spooky enough to keep me interested and pressing forward.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Nothing. The voice was clear, easy to hear, and understandable.

22 people found this helpful

So well-written but falls apart at the end

Any additional comments?

Julia Heaberlin is talented -- no question there. She has created a genuinely nuanced, conflicted, fully 3-D protagonist. She also knows how to write; on a sentence-to-sentence level, this is lovely work. Such a shame that the plot & characterization, along with any trace of verisimilitude, completely falls apart (ie. goes all "movie of the week") at the very end. Still worth a listen & I look forward to her next work where, I hope, she'll have worked out all the kinks.

43 people found this helpful