Really fun book!

What made the experience of listening to Steelheart the most enjoyable?

Sanderson has great creativity and twists throughout the book. Hardly any dull interludes are included. The action and descriptions are excellent. MacLeod Andrews does an amazing job with the narration.

What did you like best about this story?

It does a great job of pulling you right in. Within just a few pages the listener is hooked and has a hard time stepping away from the action that Sanderson creates.

What does MacLeod Andrews bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Andrews is superb. He brings the characters to life with vivid color. I can't imagine anyone doing a better job.

Any additional comments?

While I am 30 or so years past the primary target market for this book, I really appreciate how the work was handled. An exciting fantasy that is "clean" is a wonderful thing.

64 people found this helpful

He got the idea from a near traffic accident

I always find it fascinating where writers get their ideas and, according to an article by Rachel Brutsch of the Deseret News, Brandon Sanderson was cut off in traffic one day and immediately thought of the other driver, “You’re lucky I don’t have super powers because I would totally blow your car off the road.” That immediate thought horrified him; and he thought, “Its a good thing I don’t have superpowers.” Then he pondered, “What if the evil guys had all of the super powers?” That idea was the essence for his new Y.A. series, “Reckoning.”
Steeheart is a super-villain. He is one of many that received their power from a star called Calamity that appeared in the sky one day. Most thought the people that received these new found powers would use them for the benefit of mankind; wrong. With ultimate power comes ultimate corruption.
Steelheart has the strength of 10 men. He’s virtually indestructible, he can fly and when he’s enraged he can turn inanimate objects into steel. He exercised that particular power to transform most of Chicago and part of Lake Michigan before becoming the emperor of “Newcago.”
David Charleston was an eight year old boy when he saw Steelheart murder his father. Ten years has passed and David can think of only one thing; bringing Steelheart down. He is just a normal human and decides to recruit another group of humans, called “Reckoners” to help him. Reckoners study those like Steelheart, to learn their weaknesses.
This is a story that has been told many times, the struggle between good and evil, but this time Superman is not on our side; can good still win?
Its billed as a Y.A. book, and there is some romance that is usually associated with such genre, it does not, however, overwhelms the story; anyone that like Sci-Fi adventure should like this book. It is, after all, by Brandon Sanderson; and, by all indications it is the start of an epic tale.

382 people found this helpful

Captivating but somewhat childish

I liked the story and the characters. However, it is written from an 18 year old perspective and I think this may at times bother older "readers".

46 people found this helpful

Great narration of an almost great story

I really wanted to like this book. The premise and opening chapters made it sound like exactly what I would want to read, and I've heard good things about Sanderson's other books. Unfortunately I never managed to get into Steelheart. From start to finish it went exactly how these stories are supposed to go. Every interaction, every conflict, every twist felt stale to varying degrees. The ending was satisfying in exactly the way somebody told the author an ending is supposed to be satisfying, and the main character comes of age like a main character coming of age. There is witty banter and moral/philosophical discussion in the right places, but it comes off as clunky.

There were enough good aspects that I'm certainly going to try some of the author's other work, but I wouldn't recommend Steelheart.

15 people found this helpful

wondrous storytelling

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

yes, but i couldn't. hey! i have a day job! LOL it took 2 days. after writing a bunch of SQL and LINQ code for 6 hours straight ON A SATURDAY, this story was a welcome reward. even though i had to be up on sunday at 7 a.m., i kept listening until i was finished at a little after 3 a.m. yup, i was totally engrossed!

Any additional comments?

i'm attracted to stories where a person or group of people are up against a seemingly impossible situation, and what's more impossible than trying to kill the most powerful super villain, especially when you have no superpowers yourself?

this is the situation our protagonist, david, finds himself in. david is at the bank with his father the day steelheart decides to take over Chicago. during a melee with another "epic," super-powered human, david's father manages to injure steelheart by accident. as any paranoid super villain would, steelheart decides to utterly destroy the bank and everyone in it to hide the fact that someone as seemingly impervious to any type of attack as he's supposed to be was some how injured. david barely manages to escape, and he knows that steelheart will go to any lengths to protect his secret.

there are layers of conflict in this story. the outer layers are obvious- the conflicts between battling epics for the domination and subjugation of normal humans. the middle layers- the conflicts between characters. the inner layers- the conflicts raging within each character. i can't say much more w/o spoiling some of the story. sanderson seamlessly weaves these layers together, creating a rich depthness of character, and you can't help but wonder what you'd really do. the characters connect with you, and each character's viewpoint is distinct enough that different listeners would undoubtedly decide which character's viewpoint matches their own. i actually found myself wavering between 2 drastically differing viewpoints- prof's and megan's. both are cogent arguments.

the pacing of this story is perfect. the action sequences are exciting, and the dialogue is spot on. it is meaningful and believable. there are a few nice twists and turns in the story.

the narration is great. i have been a fan of macleod andrews since i heard him narrate the sandman slim series. his gritty voice matches our young protagonist, david's. he also does a great job voicing the other characters.

106 people found this helpful

comicbook based wasn't my taste but narrator great

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

if you like comic book super heros its great just not my taste.

What was most disappointing about Brandon Sanderson’s story?

not well advertised as comicbook style

Which character – as performed by MacLeod Andrews – was your favorite?

I really like this mans ability to run the gambit of voices. I so far like them all. The deep male Russian style accent is my favorite so far.

Could you see Steelheart being made into a movie or a TV series? Who should the stars be?

With the love for comicon, avengers batman etc sure

Any additional comments?

Good book just not for me. Keep up the good work there are plenty out there that love this type of thing.

60 people found this helpful

Slapdash and scatterbrained superhero YA

Slightly more mature than a Captain Underpants storyline.

I wish the book summaries would clearly tell you which books target young adults. Feels like Sanderson phones in his YA stories and the resulting books are underwhelming. With Skyward, I thought perhaps my expectations skewed my opinion, since I went into the book expecting Way of Kings or Mistborn level writing, and hadn’t realized it was a YA book. With this book, however, I checked the reviews (albeit after my blind purchase during a sale, dang it), and therefore started listening knowing this was a YA book. Plus, you know, superheroes.

Beyond the interesting premise (what if all superheroes were evil?), this YA book is a bundle of poorly written contradictions.
It’s both (A) a dark story about a child seeing his dad murdered by superhero Steelheart, spending a decade nursing his need for vengeance in an orphanage/sweatshop, and then joining the Reckoners as they rationalize violence and mayhem in the name of the “greater good” of killing evil superheroes and (B) a slapstick comedy about an 18 year old spouting goofy metaphors, paling around with a Scottish/Australian who says bagpipes are made of dragon hearts and unicorn horns, and figuring out what random things negate what random super powers (like the guy who can only be killed if exactly 37 people attack or the guy whose weakness is pretty women... really?!). I think this would have been a better story if Sanderson went all-in with either path.. but trying to walk both just lost me. My disappointment is heightened because Sanderson is usually so meticulous with his world building and rules that I can’t at first fathom but ultimately are consistent and make sense to me by the end. Here, the ending is trite and too convenient to bring any gravitas to the story.

Other downsides include way too much dialogue (especially for a YA superhero action book), slow narration (which I kept bumping up to nearly 2.0 by the end), and the dreaded Sanderson Spawned Swearing that must begin with S. In Stormlight Archives we have “shards,” in Skyward we have “scud,” and here in Steelheart we have not one, but two made up cuss words in “spark” and “splonce.” Why?! It’s not clever or effective. At this point it’s beyond annoying. ... come to think of it, that’s also three books/series that being with S... what’s with that?!

Not the worst listen I’ve sat through. But, I will not be continuing on with this series.

5 people found this helpful

I gave it a chance...

I'm sorry to say after being an avid fan of the Mistborn series and being excited to listen to Steelheart, I was incredibly disappointed. Maybe comic book fans can more readily overlook the plot holes and stupid assumptions, but unfortunately I couldn't really stomach a lot of this book. The "powers" and "weaknesses" were equally ridiculous at times, and overall it was caddy and silly. It did have it's moments, but aside from giving Mr. Sanderson a chance to prove this book's worth, I certainly would have passed. :( I guess when I get to the Alloy of Law series, I'll have to check some reviews first - unfortunate.

34 people found this helpful

So-so story, fun narration

Would you try another book from Brandon Sanderson and/or MacLeod Andrews?

Probably

Would you recommend Steelheart to your friends? Why or why not?

For young adults who appreciate the superhero genre

Have you listened to any of MacLeod Andrews’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

MacLeod Andrews made the Morgue Drawer series so much more enjoyable.

If this book were a movie would you go see it?

No

Any additional comments?

Sanderson is a good YA author that older adults can also appreciate. I quite liked The Way of Kings, and was able to overlook some of the small annoyances. With the overall high rating for Steelheart, i bought it. This book however, would have fared better as a graphic novel to be enjoyed by those who love the superhero genre. The book has an age old premise: that power can corrupt. It includes the now standard Sanderson young (annoying) romance, and humor that isn't funny. Cliches abound, starting with the names -- David, the boy going up against a giant. Abraham the wise, Doc the scientist. If nothing else, Sanderson does entertain with his tales. This audio version is read by MacLeod Andrews who is also the narrator for the very funny Morgue Drawer series -- which gave this audio book instant cred from me.

27 people found this helpful

great book for a boring ride home.

love everything about the book and they choose the right person to read the book to you.

3 people found this helpful