Compelling

Eye-opening magnificently researched, argued, written and performed. Couldn’t put it down. Zubrin is a true visionary. Now I understand Elon’s and Jeff’s passion to create colonies on Mars, and now I’m a believer. Must-read for anyone interested in space and/or the future of our species.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

Good story, but the narrating...

I liked the story (sometimes the conclusions were jumped to a bit fast and without being fully substantiated, however).

The narrator was hard to listen to, especially at first. He almost sounds like he's talking with the back of his throat. Its strange and was pretty distracting. I almost considered not listening to it anymore after about 30 minutes but hung around. He says the word 'Mars' in a bizarre way too which... well is a word used frequently throughout the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Entertaining but..... that’s all

He offers many unsubstantiated theories then later states them as fact. “We should be able to... “, for example. Based on...? Wanting to, is not being able to except in a pipe dream.
‘We can manufacture fuel from in-situ (mispronounced throughout the reading) materials on the red planet.’ Yeah, if the factories existed to accomplish that but it’s unrealistic due to weight and cost to transport those, or even the component parts (steel pipe just for one example) to construct all the plants necessary. It’s a catch-22 with no viable/realistic solution path except to start over on Mars, our evolution from the Neolithic ages, to the ceramic age to the Bronze Age to the Iron Age to eventually PAST where we are now. Really? Over centuries on the red planet?
He concludes that with a snap of our fingers we will be mining materials to build communities and produce rocket fuel. With what, garden trowels and a kid’s Erector Set we bring with us?
It’s good entertainment but that’s all.
Cost projections are off by probably a hundredfold.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

good book .... but the narration!

Whew!
This narrator is PAINFUL to listen to, but the topic and ideas are compelling. A bit too esoteric near the end, but interesting none-the-less.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

What he's not...

Zubrin has an intriguing idea for a sustainable infrastructure to explore Mars. That's where his expertise ends, hard. He rambles off into geology, medicine, sociology, and other areas. These parts get tiresome quickly, and are entirely his own uninformed opinions. The thing that raised my eyebrow the most was the part where he talks about "preserving human diversity". As discussed, this is thinly veiled racist propaganda, whether he understands that or not (I think not). In any event, I enjoy Zubrin the engineer, the rest of his thoughts are rambling noise.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

The Real Science of Getting to Mars

If the book "The Martian" was of interest, then imagine how a book detailing the real science on obtaining this goal would be. For me, this was the book. Zubrin is well known in scientific circles for his engineering knowledge and mapping out the details of exploring Mars. Why did we literally end our human space exploration following the Apollo programs years ago? Is NASA a help or a hindrance in human exploration to Mars? How do we financially make this happen? How do we actually survive on the surface as we explore? What are the real dangers in obtaining this goal; not dangers invented by political opponents trying to prevent further space exploration? He lays out why humans and not just robots must go to Mars; not just to say we went, but to actually study Mars and why it is important to do so. If you have an interest in the scientific answers to these and many other questions about Mars exploration, then I highly recommend this book for you. The title, "The Case for Mars", is definitely self-explanatory about the contents of this book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Excellent! But!!!

Highly compelling! Not that I was on the boarder about space exploration but this is an excellent work on ‘why Mars’.
However, it’s also a little out dated. If you want a more recent work look at The Case For Space also by Robert Zubrin. But even that excellent book is aging fast with all the recent developments in space travel. I think this book is most relevant now as it was one of the things that convince Elon Musk to start SpaceX. Also it’s an excellent argument as to why Mars should be first on the colonization list as opposed to the moon or cislunar space.
Now for the gripes. (Sigh) I really wish engineers, rocket scientists, and astrophysicists (oh my!) would stay away from astrobiology. They are interested in it as it is relevant to the prevalence and nature of life in the universe in general and in general they tend to have a decent understanding of biology. But they don’t have a complete understanding of the more advanced and less intuitive principles such as the law of minimum complexity (which is why we don’t see pre-protozoan bacteria floating around) or the energy dynamics of organisms. And because, frankly, they see biology as a “lesser science” they think that they can make all kinds of assertions about this and that. This, in my eyes, degrades Robert Zubrin’s authority on other subjects as it makes me wonder what other important points he’s missing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Boldly go

This was a really comprehensive book on the various ways we could get to and settle on mars. It’s a shame all our recent innovations and technology focus on self and looking down at our phones instead of looking up at the stars like we did as kids

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

everything I was looking for in a book about Mars

A lot of juicy technical details. goes into some politics and what we need to do in order to help Humana to get to Mars.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

DatedAF

Be nice if audible notes that this was originally published in 1996. A few things have been added from as recently as 10!years ago to bring it more up to date, but even those things are completely dated now too.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!