Fractured Fairytale

So this is what a fairytale for grownups looks like--full of the darkest horror with wishes for a happy ending. I had very much looked forward to this book as I am a great believer in the truths that can be learned from folktales, fairy tales, mythology and the like, but this attempt at a modern re-telling did not work especially well for me.

After a painfully slow start, the story gathers steam with the subway birth of a baby which eventually devolves into a nightmare experience of parenthood. Yes, parenthood does teach us much about ourselves--from newly discovered feelings of intense love and protectiveness, to feelings of alienation and horror at the degree of rage and even impulses to violence we are capable of feeling. In the manner of fairytales, LaValle externalizes these negative feelings, embodying them in monsters and their minions, making it possible to commit the most horrific of acts and still be the perfect parent. I suppose that the author intends to embody Emma's feelings of intense love for her baby while simultaneously feeling overwhelmingly alienated from both her child and husband (postpartum depression?) but I still find her response to these dark forces hard to accept.

I did enjoy the use of NYC to create a dreamlike setting and the use of technology as a backdrop. As for the narration, this is an occasion where the author would have been better leaving it up to others--fairly expressionless and with little effort to distinguish among the characters.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

42 people found this helpful

When Papa was away at a book sale...

11.03.2017
I think I'm a 1/3 of the way through this book so far.
I love this book, even more so because I've just had the singular experience of stopping an audiobook and jotting down Patrice's slow cooker lemon chicken recipe and I'm now making it for dinner. I have never cooked from a novel. I'm excited.

11.10.2017
This book was incredible and listening to LaValle narrate it was incredible. The melding of myth and now was amazing and I wasn't even mentally tsk tsking over how the use of an iPhone or referencing Maurice Sendak will date the novel in the future because this story is timeless and it doesn't matter.
We had lemon chicken and olives again tonight.

AUDIBLE 20 REVIEW SWEEPSTAKES ENTRY

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

30 people found this helpful

The Weirdest, Most Wonderful Damn Book

The Changeling is by far the book I want to shower all my love on in 2017. I want to hug strangers in the street and whisper in their ears how amazing this audiobook is, that it’s one of the weirdest, most wonderful damn books I’ve listened to in a long time. At the heart of this modern-day fairy tale is Apolla Kagwa, a scrappy book dealer and devoted dad who wears a Baby Bjorn all over New York City and takes his infant to the playground at 4:30 every morning. After a horrific chain of events, Apollo loses his wife and son, and—wrecked with grief—sets out across the 5 boroughs on an epic quest to rescue and redeem them. The path is strewn with witches, monsters, and trolls (both the fairy tale kind and the internet kind), and Kagwa’s New York is both recognizable and completely fantastical. Victor LaValle is one of those unicorn novelists who happens to be a fabulous narrator of his own work, and as he reads you this story, his voice is like magic and butter. Above all, The Changeling is one black man’s ode to fatherhood and the lengths to which he will go to protect his family.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

23 people found this helpful

Interesting Fairy Tale Told Well

I'm amazed that anyone can read so slowly. I had to adjust the audio to 1.5x and still it sounded close to normal speech. But the prose was expertly crafted and the story kept my attention, even when there seemed lapses in time or logic. I also bought the hardbound novel, switching back and forth between them, and I think I enjoyed reading it more than listening to the author.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

22 people found this helpful

I'm surprised I made it to the end

What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?

A different narrator and faster pacing.

Has The Changeling turned you off from other books in this genre?

No, I usually love this sort of magic realism, but this one dragged.

What aspect of Victor LaValle’s performance would you have changed?

I would've liked more variable characterization. There was only one character that I noticed any vocal difference from the others. As it was, the narration was kind of droning. There are many times that it lulled me to sleep. Not very dynamic.

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

A good premise, but it didn't really follow through for me.

Any additional comments?

I normally NEVER write reviews for ANYTHING so you should know that I mean what I say here. The author narration didn't bother me that much but I'm sure it was a factor in my mediocre reaction to the book. My main gripe about The Changeling is pacing. It took soooooo long for anything to happen, and even when it started I didn't feel much urgency on behalf of the characters. If I had been reading the physical book I definitely would've given up. But with the audiobook it's easy to just leave it on in the background while driving, etc., and get on with it. Also, I found the violence in the last section pretty unnecessary. That sort of thing doesn't usually bug me but I found it gratuitous in this case.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

13 people found this helpful

unexpressive monotone narrative voice

I think this is a great story & the author a brilliant writer. But I tried to get thru listening to the book & every time the author who is also the narrator put me to sleep every time. I think for me reading the book instead of listening would have been more enjoyable. Reading allows you to use your imagination to bring the characters voices & expressions to life to suit your own satisfaction. I am aware that I may not be a reader who is as intellectually astute and sophisticated as many readers who critique review or edit professionally. But to me narrating a book is no different than performing a play or portraying a character in a movie. That character needs to come alive in order to be loved or hated or laughed at or cried for by the reader.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

Every Human is a Series of Stories

A common misconception of Fairy Tales among some adults is that they are cute, charming fantasy stories suitable for children. They are safe and everyone lives happily ever after. Victor LaValle's The Changeling is here to remind that there's a darker side to them, that some times there aren't happy endings, and that what might seem like magic to one person looks like a descent into insanity to someone else. In this Fairy Tale of New York there are enchanted islands, magic wishes and spells from across the sea, used book collectors, haunted cemeteries, and trolls (not just the internet variety -- although there are those too). It's a dark, brutal, and often shocking tale that twists the reality of modern day New York into something fantastical.

Apollo was a skinny black kid when his dad disappeared. Now he's a new father -- and LaValle does an excellent job of capturing what it's like to be a new dad in this age of technological wonders. But after the baby is born his wife Emma seems to be struggling with postpartum depression. She commits a terrifying and violent act, then vanishes. Struggling to put the pieces of his life back together, Apollo goes in search of her. Through it all, LaValle does all this without ever losing his footing in reality. I already mentioned how he nails what it's like to be a new dad -- cheesy jokes and stereotypes and all. He also manages to get what it's like to see parents age over the years, becoming shadows of themselves. And Apollo's friendship with Afghanistan war veteran and fellow used-book seller Patrice is a delight.

While I don't think it's a perfect book, I'm still giving it five stars. One of the characters got off way too easy for my tastes and I wish there had been a little bit more gray there. But with everything else it had going for it -- the strong sense of social consciousness, the captivating sense of magic and mystery, and Apollo's quest to find out what happened and why -- I loved every minute of it and was sad when it ended. And I'm already looking at what other LaValle books I haven't yet read.

LaValle reads his own book here. While his narration is more of a flat read, I found his voice, cadence, and performance of the characters wonderful and immersing -- a sure part of the spell this book cast on me.

Fans of Gaiman's American Gods, Matt Ruff's Lovecraft Country, or Lev Grossman's The Magicians -- don't miss this one.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Very Slow Start, But Pays Off Big

This is a slow burn of a story that demands you trust it for a good long while before it begins the fairytale adventure aspects of its journey, but boy does it deliver. Magical realism in the modern era done right. Finely detailed so that you don't miss a single moment, big or small. Plotted by a master who left no stone unturned. Bravo!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Best Book I've Listened to This Year

This book was recommended by a facebook group and I really wasn't interested but decided to give it a chance....so glad I did. The writing is just beautiful and the characters are richly drawn. I knew nothing about the story going in and that was part of the fun - I really had no idea where the story was going but what a ride!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Urban Fantasy of the Capital "L" Literature Crowd

This is an excellent book, well written, passionate, and enough autobiographical details to make the protagonist seem real. LaValle has a gift for words and spins some spectacular metaphors and similes. The fantastical elements are subtle and not overused.

Narration - I cringe when authors insist on reading their works (I'm looking at you Jeff Lindsay and Stephen King), but you would think LaValle was a voice actor. He does an amazing job and adds to the production with a tone, pacing, and insight that only the author can apply correctly.

Overall this was a great book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful