Felt like listening to a Maths book read aloud

John Dominic Crossan's meditational reflection on the Lord's Prayer (Our Father) has some intriguing concepts and ideas (eg. "God is Justice - distributive justice, not penal justice.")

Going through the Lord's Prayer phrase by phrase Crossan shares his take on theology with the listener. He argues that the Lord's Prayer is a Jewish prayer on the lips of Christianity for all people. It is therefore a universal prayer. From this stance he starts to examine the prayer in more detail.

Early on in the book, he introduces the listener to a technical poetic device that plays an important role in his explanation of the Lord's Prayer (as in Matthew) in large parts of the book, namely parallelism. While myself versed in the Hebrew Bible's poetic devices, I wondered who else that listens to this book would be? I also thought that in his reading Walter Dixon tried his best to deal with parallelism by accentuating words, but I didn't think that it worked. I am not sure if people would grasp such a concept without seeing it in front of them, thus I felt a PDF download could've illuminated the book.

Although large parts of the book were tedious and at times almost impossible to listen to, there were a few very interesting concepts. I liked the way that he interpreted Psalm 82 in the light of consequences instead of punishment. His background information on Jesus was also worthwhile to listen to.

Yet, a lot of it felt like the religious equivalent to a Mathematics Handbook being read aloud. While I have a lot of respect for Walter Dixon and appreciates his effort in reading the book, I do think that the technical nature of the book doesn't do him justice. This was definitely not his best performance. (His pronunciation of certain Greek words Crossan used was most of the times almost completely unrecognisable.)

At a place in the book Crossan makes himself guilty of a etymological fallacy when discussing the word "sacrifice." He says it comes from the Latin for "make holy." Then he explains the concept behind the English word along the etymological meaning of the word. The problem is just that it doesn't work in other languages, like German, Dutch and Afrikaans. It sounds very much like the "missing the target"-explanation that is read into the concept of "sin" by some televangelists.

All in all, it is a technical book with a lot of promise, but which really doesn't lean itself to audiobook format. I really think the trend of reading the New Testament in the shadow of the Empire, which Crossan also does, is a hermeneutic key forced in a lock that it shouldn't open.

I would strongly recommend that you buy the written version of the book. It is not the best of Crossan.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Fascinating perspective

Dr. Croissant and his work have always impressed me and made me go “wow” out loud a number of times. This book was no exception. I did have to be a bit more patient than with his other work for the payoff, but, without fail, I’m again feeling blown away. I think the Lord’s Prayer takes on a new life with these considerations included.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Awesome!

JD Crossan has been filling in the blanks from my Catholic education. I’m so appreciative of the the connections he makes between the biblical texts and the social, linguistic, literary, and historical context that generated those texts.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

APPEALS TO HEART AND MIND AS NO OTHER

"HYMN OF HOPE FOR ALL HUMANITY". TELLS IT LIKE IT IS AUTHORITATIVELY. CONSUMATE MASTERY OF SCRIPTURE.
"ENOUGHISM" IS THE NORM!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

powerful & enlightening

Crossen is one of my favorite authors. His, as well as Borgs books, along with Westar, and most off all, my church have guided me through the long illnesses of my Mother and then my Wife. Nothing relieves my sorrow and emptiness like sound teaching.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!