Exceptional voice cast, unconventional format

Would you try another book from Neal Stephenson and Nicole Galland and/or the narrators?

Absolutely

Would you listen to another book narrated by the narrators?

Yes

Any additional comments?

This was not my favorite, but it was fun and it held my attention.

The book is written entirely in the form of documentation produced by various characters. The first act of the book is entirely composed of a single document written by one character, so the book feels like a familiar first-person perspective story. Later, the book shifts to documents written by other characters, and that familiarity breaks down. Much of the later sections contain chat logs and IM transcripts.

The two main characters are Melisande Stokes, who specializes in ancient languages, and Tristan Lyons - a military man who loves science. I found this paralleled the dual authors Nicole Galland, who I understand specializes in historical fiction, and Neal Stephenson, who takes joy in writing about science, technology, ancient warfare, and specifically money (as a technology). I suspect the writing duties fell mainly on Nicole Galland, but I would start to hear Neal Stephenson's voice in the ruminations of Tristan, and later any character who needed to explain technology or swordsmanship. Also, I am pretty sure Neal Stephenson wrote the epic poem towards the end that features the viking sacking of an unconventional target.

Like most books, I read this partially on my Kindle and partially as an audio book on Audible - my preferred way to consume a book, as I can read comfortably in a chair after work, and then continue over audio while driving. The audio presentation featured a full cast, which is wonderful, though often one character was speaking through another characters document, so different performers would read the same character depending on the document being read - which was kind of... unsettling. Also, the chat logs necessitated a name and timestamp on every reply, which crippled the rhythm when the replies were brief.

Any fan of either of these authors is probably going to enjoy this book. Also, it would appeal to fans of time travel and those who enjoy blurring the lines between fantasy and science fiction.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

143 people found this helpful

Really, really fun

Would you listen to The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O. again? Why?

No -- or at least not for a decade or so. I would want to have forgotten the plot.

What was one of the most memorable moments of The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O.?

The Lay of Walmart. I say no more.

Have you listened to any of the narrators’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

No. I was at first suspicious of the multiple-narrator format since I often don't like that mix. But this one worked for me, and was not distracting. The voice of Melisande was especially good.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

No!! I loved listening to it, and looked forward to being in my car to do so, but I'm not a masochist.

Any additional comments?

For those interested in format, it is fun (especially for a historian, which I am) to have it written as a series of documents. They are chatty enough and contain enough dialogue that they do not seem dry, but the shifting perspectives drive the narrative in interesting and provocative ways.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

94 people found this helpful

Stephenson teams up for time travel

Neal Stephenson has written some of the most densely plotted sci-fi thrillers of the past few decades. In this book he teamed up with Nicole Galland, who has contributed to several of the Mongoliad books as well as writing several books set in early England, to create a lighter-than-usual book on time travel. 

D.O.D.O. is a secret US agency, the Department of Diachronic Operations. The agency has been established because it has been determined that magic was both real and common up until 1851. At that point magic weakened and then became nonexistent.

Melisande Stokes, a polyglot and specialist in languages, is recruited to assist in the investigation of what event might have triggered this change. And it's clear that something has gone terribly wrong because the book opens with her own penned narrative of how she somehow became trapped in London of 1851 with no apparent way back.

To aid the work the agency also recruits the services of a famous Harvard physicist and a 250 year-old Hungarian witch. The physicist has created a device in which magic still works, while the witch was encouraged to extend her life (apparently by Melisande herself) in order to assist the work.

D.O.D.O. faces several issues, not the least of which is a knack for embarrassing acronyms. There are elements in the government that want to defund the agency. This leads to an attempt (ala Jodi Taylor) to go back in time to place a rare book in a spot where it can be dug up and sold to help fund operations. Unlike the operations of Taylor's St. Mary's historians this is a much more complex operation, requiring multiple trips into the past and into various timelines to try to get the operation to work properly. During one of these multiple trips it becomes apparent that some other entity is interfering with the plan. This leads them to an earlier point in England where a beautiful Irish witch, former lover of Christopher Marlowe and correspondent/spy for Irish pirate Grace O'Malley, is recruited but clearly has an agenda all her own.

Galland offers a lighter touch with more humor than Stephenson normally offers on his own, and brings up some interesting historical ideas, such as that many of the plays of Shakespeare, even Romeo and Juliet, have intentionally anti-Irish themes. The story ranges from early San Francisco to Istanbul with some really wonderful characters. It's told through various points of view, including snippets of interoffice memos and redacted documents.

For those who are expecting a straight-ahead Stephenson thriller this is a book that could bring some disappointment. But anyone with an interest in books on history and time-travel this is a very fun shift in the Stephenson canon, with more attention to character and historic detail than many time travel books.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

91 people found this helpful

Poor Audio Quality

What did you like best about The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O.? What did you like least?

This is NOT a review of the whole novel As far as story and plot goes, the 40 minutes I've listened to so far is great. What is not great is the audio quality of this release (using Enhanced format, highest available on Audible). There seems to be a sibilant "echo" after certain phrases in the novel, most noticeable when the 's' sound is heard, that I have only encountered before when listening to audio files that have been transcoded one too many times.

I CANNOT confirm whether or not the cd release has the same issue, so for now I'm going to put this down to a hiccup in audible's transcoding process from the master files to their proprietary format. (encrypted AAC (LC) SBR m4b, essentially).

If possible (I'm not sure if you can edit reviews), I will update this review if and/or when this has been fixed.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

55 people found this helpful

About that Ending

Over the years I have seen many people complain about Stephenson's endings and never really got the problem, but this novel really seemed to end like a Season One cliffhanger on a tv show more than a stand-alone novel (or even the first novel in a series, which I don't know if this is meant to be). If the story had ended just a few scenes earlier I would have felt it was abrupt but answered my major questions... instead it seemed to go from messy conclusion to plot-point-rich opening to the really important stuff.

I would have given the story a 4, maybe a 3, but the disappointment at the end (relatively mild as it might be) tipped me over.

Still, the performances were great (recognized a number of familiar voices) and it overall delivered on a fun concept.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

48 people found this helpful

Bureaucratic time travel with an eye for details

Any additional comments?

This is one of those books that took me a few days to fully process after finishing it, as a result I can safely say this is a good book.

This book is definitely not about characters X, Y, and Z doing cool things and beating the Big Bad. No, it is the records of the rise and fall of the organization D.O.D.O. I didn't realize this at first, but once I did, it all came together and I could appreciate it and enjoy it all the more.

All that aside, what we have here is the proving that magic existed once, but then it stopped suddenly on one auspicious day. How to bring back magic in a limited fashion and using it to send people back in time to manipulate things so the world becomes a little better, or before the enemies unseen do it first. Great plan right? Well at least until bureaucracy rears its ugly head. Seriously, the skill with which Stephenson wrote the bureaucratic nightmare and the awful coworkers was so realistic it made me uncomfortable. Additionally there are all kinds of very accurate portrayals of the past that breath life into it. Did you know whalebone bodices had to be custom made? Whodathunkit?

That's all you really need to know. If you like Stephenson's other works, or a totally different retreading of the time travel genre, I recommend this book to you. Overall, I doubt many people would be disappointed that they picked this one up.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

45 people found this helpful

Not sure about this book

Great narration by a great crew of speakers. The story, however, is full of promise but comes up short. It seemed to me that the authors were not sure what direction to take this book, but had a bunch of cool short story ideas and tried to fit those ideas in wether they made sense or not for the overall plot. Which, I’m still confused as to what the plot was. They then left it off like this was the beginning of a series. I will remember this as the book that could have been great.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

40 people found this helpful

Long but interesting

Where does The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O. rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

Average

Who was your favorite character and why?

none

What about the narrators’s performance did you like?

Better then average.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

no

Any additional comments?

Although this writer seems to produce books as though he is being paid by the word he is
different and unique.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

36 people found this helpful

Meh...I feel like I wasted my time.

A lot of little mini adventures and following characters around doing nothing. All that slowly builds to not much of an ending....
Performers were good though. They are about the only good thing about the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

26 people found this helpful

Imaginative, Intriguing and Captivating.

Having read and listened to so many books over several decades, I am not easily impressed. I liked everything about this one. Each narrator was excellent! Great characters and not one of them got on my nerves hahahaha. With most books I usually am busy doing something like painting while listening but I found myself stopping, staring at nothing, listening. So yes it's meaty. If you want Fantasy, Science fiction, Fictional history, time travel, etc then this is for you.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

25 people found this helpful