glaring mistakes an omissions

I just purchased the book and quickly noticed several glaring errors. Firstly the chapters are missnumbered from the very beginning. There are at 3 chapter 6! The first two (chapters 2 & 3) chapters give the Title of the chapter and the name of narrator, but later chapters omit this. I don't know how these glaring omissions happened. I love the YouTube channels that made this book and I'm very upset their work is treated so unprofessionally. I would love to give it five stars but right now, unless changes are made I can't

3 people found this helpful

Oh my sweet summer child! Grayarea, Smokescreen..

Thoroughly enjoyed listening to some of my favorite GOT voices. Channels from youtube that I've come to rely on for my GOT reviews and updates; voices that MADE the show that much more alluring and fun. Chapter 10, Grayarea is my girl! Grey was my voice of reason, and I couldn't wait to watch her reaction videos with every episode. She now is reviewing book chapters from GRRM's first book. Jema from Secrets of the Citadel is so knowledgeable, and I enjoy all of her work. Chris from Smokescreen reminders me of my best friends, and I wish I could buy him a brew! He would livestream after every episode, and I LOVED watching the day after. He was so enjoyable to watch. Protostark! Sunday is coming man! GOT academy is a great channel, and I wish I would have found out about this channel before season 8 of the show.

I've NEVER liked sci-fi or fantasy but GOT changed the game. There is no show that came take it's place. This book helped me through my GOT depression.

Great read. Well worth the purchase, y'all!!

1 person found this helpful

Most of this is great

There are a number of narrators with heavy accents who are almost impossible to understand. After struggling to understand them I ultimately skipped those chapters, which is a shame because they were probably full of interesting information but if I can’t make out what you’re saying I will never know (this doesn’t include Gemma or Because Geek). The voices I could understand were great. I subscribe to or occasionally watch videos from most of those authors. Overall, it’s slightly disjointed which is expected when a book has so many diverse authors, but it’s quite good, relatable and interesting. The conversational YouTube video tone makes it an easy listen with the exception of the chapters discussed above (which is why I had to give a three for performance, the voices I could understand deserve a 5). Overall, it was worth the credit to hear and I will probably listen to the coherent parts again.

1 person found this helpful

Uneven Narration

I was very much looking forward to this book because I'm subscribed to several of these authors' channels. It was great to hear them explain exactly what makes us Ice and Fire Nerds, to use Chris's phrase, so obsessive about the show and books. If your friends and family just don't get it, lend them this book.

The writers each read their own piece and they're very good. As YouTubers they've somewhat mastered the art of speaking at the perfect rate. This is the first audio book in a long time that I haven't had to kick up to 2X speed. Gil Kidron from GOT Academy especially stands out. He read with wonderful energy and verve. The only letdown was the reader for chapter 6 (sorry, I don't know his name), who sounded as though he was automated; no inflection or emotion whatsoever.

1 person found this helpful

Big Game of Thrones fan... didn't like this

I'm a big game of thrones fan but didn't find this book interesting. I've tried several times to get through it but turn it off after 15-30 minutes everytime. I respect what the multiple authors have done but it's just not a collection of stories that catches my ear.

Over Priced for an Amateurly Recorded Audio Book

The sound quality and performances by many of the voice actors is severely lacking. I skipped one chapter as the quality and stiff, fake delivery was so grating. Additionally, the essays in each chapter weren't that interesting or informative. I do not recommend this as either a physical book or audio book. It would be better kept as a blog post.

love these podcasters

Struggled to get through the robot read chapter, would have given 5 stars. Good book otherwise...

love GOT

love Game of Thrones and thoroughly enjoyed these narratives. can't wait to heat their take on the final season.

FAR BEYOND MY EXPECTATIONS!!

I was interested in this audiobook because as a hardcore ASOIAF fan, I listen to some of these video bloggers on the regular: Chris from SmokeScreen, Gemma from Secrets of the Citadel and GrayArea offer a familiar and often thought-provoking perspective. But can I just say...Gil Kidron BLEW. MY. MIND. At first, I wasn't sure if I could handle his Oberyn Schwarzenegger-esque accent for an extended time, but it quickly grew on me. His insight, analogies, and comparisons from the past to present, fiction to real-life history and current events...coupled with the psychoanalysis of the characters was just exceptional. He delivered his essay like that school professor you wished you had. I enjoy GOT beyond the entertainment level with its complex characters, storylines which challenge you to see beyond the obvious. This story is much deeper than complex than most realize on so many levels. And I think he nailed it when he said we are captivated by it because we haven't had the experience or history of monarchies, fights for power etc. How do i know this is true? After GOT, I dove into everything British history. EVERYTHING. I had zero interest in this topic before GOT. The insight as to what may have and how GRRM's craft was inspired is truly a look behind the most amazing curtain of writing and storytelling. My only complaint is that I wish it were longer. Bravo to everyone!!

This book is everything!

Some of the best minds and voices in the fandom wrote and narrated this masterpiece!