Good book, Narrator awful!

I have always read how some Narrator's are bad and then listened to that book and not agreed. However, this time listening was like pulling teeth. I couldn't tell which character was which as there was very little tone change per character. It also didn't help that 3 separate Narrator's were chosen to read a trilogy. Next time, please select one Narrator for all 3 books so we can at least keep the character's consistent.

18 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Creepy but good

Creepy used to be one of my favorite genres before I somehow wimped out and couldn't take it anymore. But, this one had just enough creep factor without creeping me out. Totally enjoyed this series. Listened to all 3, but got the other two from my local library. I liked Phil Gigante in the first book. I would have preferred the same narrator for all 3. But, it didn't kill the series for me, so I guess it was ok.

5 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Book and story is great, but narrator is not

What made the experience of listening to The Hollow the most enjoyable?

the story is great. I love Nora Roberts books and I also love the supernatural, this book has the best of both worlds.

What did you like best about this story?

I liked the mystery of Anne Hawkins, Giles, and Hester's story, along with the suspense of where the group of six falls into their line. The "demon" is also something to wonder about.

How did the narrator detract from the book?

She seemed to be reading the story for the first time. Drawing out the first syllable of each sentence as if she were stalling for time to read the emotion supposed to be put into this sentence. It's annoying, and amateur. There are also obvious flubs throughout the reading where she mispronounced or started to say the wrong word, then quickly righted it mid-word. If I were someone listening to an audiobook for the first time, this would have been my last.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

parts made me laugh, parts made me cry but only because I was able to get past the horrible narration and view it from my mind's eye.

Any additional comments?

I'll never listen to another audiobook read by Marie Caliendo, even if it is a great book. I'd rather buy the written book and read it aloud to myself.

5 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Unbelievably bad narration!!!!!!!

What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?

Different narrator.

What was your reaction to the ending? (No spoilers please!)

Didn't get there. Couldn't handle the cadence.

How did the narrator detract from the book?

Worst narration I have ever experienced and i've listened to a couple of books voiced by volunteers.

What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?

Frustration and anger because of the narration.

Any additional comments?

I'm sure Nora Roberts and her producers make plenty of money so please don't cut corners when it comes to the talent. The performance is HUGE for an audio book! Duuuhhh!

4 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Story's great! Narrator HORRIBLE!

Part one of this series is great and Phil Giganti was an awesome narrator for part one. I have no understanding why they would switch the narrator with one that is just so bad. In book one Phil Giganti gave Leila a New York accent in this book you can't tell the difference between the women and who are the men. I am just trying to get through because the story really is good and I'm looking forward to book 3. Unless you get these stories at a lower rate like I did you are better off reading book don't waste your credit. The story is really interesting Nora Roberts really is a great author. I'm a JD Robb fan and these stories don't disappoint. Happy Reading!

3 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Great Story...but

The narrator is AWFUL!!!! The narrator of the first book-Phil Gigante- is amazing. So why oh why did they change the narrator after the first book?!?!?!
Truly unfortunate because it's an entertaining story. It's difficult to listen to when the distinction between characters is at best vague and at worst vague and inconsistent- as if she can't keep them straight. I think the low point in this book was a plot-critical scene in which a character is reading aloud. The narrator made her sound like an illiterate teenager with no recognition of punctuation! It was so bad- I actually struggled to follow what she was saying. Tragic. Beyond that, I became annoyed when the narrators portrayal of a well established character comes off dull witted and marble mouthed or worse...ditzy! It's a real downer when you've invested in a character for an entire first book only to be annoyed by the sound of their voice for the rest of the story. A real let down.

7 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

The Hollow

I like the story. The author brought depth to his characters. The characters are warm and alive in the story. The story moves along well in some places you hold your breath because not sure what is going to happen. I like this book because of the various emotions that are displayed in this bring you to the edge of your seat, or make sigh with relief, and love the romance that the author brings in with the six main characters. Especially the two characters who have to work together but rub each other the wrong way. It is very good book. One I enjoyed very much.

7 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Sounded like "Scooby Doo"

What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?

Different voice talent or direction to talent.

What was most disappointing about Nora Roberts’s story?

Sounded like Darci from a bad Scooby Doo episode.

What didn’t you like about Marie Caliendo’s performance?

Too fake and "dramatic"

2 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Frequent Listener

Promised myself I'd finish the series after taking heat on book 1. Wasn't thrilled at first on the change in narrator, however after a while I got used to it and moved on. I liked the way the author tied the first book to this one, kept it short but refreshed the story line. Some authors in series tend to drag too much of previous books into the next one in the series, Nora didn't do that as much as others.

Liked the characters, this book focused on the story and the background on two of the other characters. I guess the last two of the six will be in the last book in the series. Not my normal fare, but again, I found this enjoyable and easy to listen to.

2 les gens ont trouvé cela utile

Too Long and Drawn Out

I agree with a previous poster that this story was very slow and the "sex scenes" were gratuitous and embarrassing. I actually had to fast forward through some of them, they were so silly and immature.

I picked this Blood Brothers series because I thought it would be an interesting story and a little spooky. The first book was pretty good but this second one is more like a sappy romance novel through 90% of the story with only 10% that actually contributed to the overall storyline of the series. It seems like it was intentionally fluffed up just to fill pages and still have some storyline left for the third book.

I did like the female narrator. I purchased the first installment Blood Brothers from a retail store and the male narrator was horrendous! So, this was an improvement.

Now that I'm two books into the trilogy I feel I have no choice but to listen to the third to tie up the story. I REALLY hope it is more meaty than this one and sticks to the storyline instead of adding a bunch of teenage romance novel filler!

2 les gens ont trouvé cela utile