Gratuit avec l'essai de 30 jours
-
The Sound of Gravel
- A Memoir
- Narrateur(s): Ruth Wariner
- Durée: 9 h et 4 min
- Version intégrale Livre audio
- Catégories: Religion et spiritualité, Christianisme
Échec de l'ajout au panier.
Échec de l'ajout à la liste d'envies.
Échec de la suppression de la liste d’envies.
Échec du suivi du balado
Ne plus suivre le balado a échoué
Abonnement à Audible
14,95$ par mois
Acheter pour 32,92$
Aucun mode de paiement valide enregistré.
Nous sommes désolés. Nous ne pouvons vendre ce titre avec ce mode de paiement
Les auditeurs ont également apprécié...
-
Shattered Dreams
- My Life as a Polygamist's Wife
- Auteur(s): Irene Spencer
- Narrateur(s): Laural Merlington
- Durée: 14 h et 6 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Irene Spencer did as she felt God commanded in marrying her brother-in-law, Verlan LeBaron, becoming his second wife. When the government raided the fundamentalist, polygamous Mormon village of Short Creek, Arizona, Irene and her family fled to Verlan's brothers' Mexican ranch. They lived in squalor and desolate conditions in the Mexican desert with Verlan's six brothers, one sister, and numerous wives and children.
Auteur(s): Irene Spencer
-
We Were Rich and We Didn't Know It
- A Memoir of My Irish Boyhood
- Auteur(s): Tom Phelan
- Narrateur(s): Gerard Doyle
- Durée: 6 h et 13 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
In the tradition of Frank McCourt’s Angela’s Ashes and Alice Taylor’s To School Through the Fields, Tom Phelan’s We Were Rich and We Didn't Know It is a heartfelt and masterfully written memoir of growing up in Ireland in the 1940s. We Were Rich and We Didn't Know It recounts Tom’s upbringing in an isolated, rural community from the day he was delivered by the local midwife. With tears and laughter, it speaks to the strength of the human spirit in the face of life's adversities.
Auteur(s): Tom Phelan
-
Church of Lies
- Auteur(s): Flora Jessop, Paul T. Brown
- Narrateur(s): Eve Bianco
- Durée: 10 h et 36 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
"I was one of 28 children born to my dad and his three wives. Indoctrinated to believe that the outside world was evil, and that I resided among the righteous, I was destined to marry a man chosen for me by the Prophet. I would then live in harmony with my sister-wives, bear many children, and obey and serve my future husband in this life and throughout eternity. But my innocence didn't last long." Flora goes on from there to tell the dramatic true story of how she ultimately escaped and has been rescuing women and children from the FLDS.
Auteur(s): Flora Jessop, Autres
-
Born with Teeth
- A Memoir
- Auteur(s): Kate Mulgrew
- Narrateur(s): Kate Mulgrew
- Durée: 10 h et 40 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Audie Award, Narration by Author, 2016. Raised by unconventional Irish Catholics who knew "how to drink, how to dance, how to talk, and how to stir up the devil", Kate Mulgrew grew up with poetry and drama in her bones. But in her mother, a would-be artist burdened by the endless arrival of new babies, young Kate saw the consequences of a dream deferred.
-
-
This book is a Love Letter to Tim Hagan
- Écrit par Todd Herron le 2018-03-02
Auteur(s): Kate Mulgrew
-
Cult Insanity
- A Memoir of Polygamy, Prophets, and Blood Atonement
- Auteur(s): Irene Spencer
- Narrateur(s): Laural Merlington
- Durée: 10 h et 11 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
In Cult Insanity, Spencer reveals the outrageous behavior of her brother-in-law Ervil---a self-proclaimed prophet who determined he was called to set the house of God in order---and how he terrorized their colony. Claiming to be God's avenger and to have a license to kill in the name of God, Ervil ordered the murders of friends and family members, eliminating all those who challenged his authority. Cult Insanity is a riveting, terrifying memoir of polygamist life under the tyranny of a madman.
Auteur(s): Irene Spencer
-
My Mother, Munchausen's and Me
- A True Story of Betrayal and a Shocking Family Secret
- Auteur(s): Helen Naylor
- Narrateur(s): Helen Naylor
- Durée: 10 h et 15 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Ten years ago, Helen Naylor discovered her mother, Elinor, had been faking debilitating illnesses for 30 years. After Elinor’s self-induced death, Helen found her diaries, which Elinor wrote daily for more than 50 years. The diaries reveal not only the inner workings of Elinor’s twisted mind and self-delusion, but also shocking revelations about Helen’s childhood. Everything Helen knew about herself and her upbringing was founded on a lie.
Auteur(s): Helen Naylor
-
Shattered Dreams
- My Life as a Polygamist's Wife
- Auteur(s): Irene Spencer
- Narrateur(s): Laural Merlington
- Durée: 14 h et 6 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Irene Spencer did as she felt God commanded in marrying her brother-in-law, Verlan LeBaron, becoming his second wife. When the government raided the fundamentalist, polygamous Mormon village of Short Creek, Arizona, Irene and her family fled to Verlan's brothers' Mexican ranch. They lived in squalor and desolate conditions in the Mexican desert with Verlan's six brothers, one sister, and numerous wives and children.
Auteur(s): Irene Spencer
-
We Were Rich and We Didn't Know It
- A Memoir of My Irish Boyhood
- Auteur(s): Tom Phelan
- Narrateur(s): Gerard Doyle
- Durée: 6 h et 13 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
In the tradition of Frank McCourt’s Angela’s Ashes and Alice Taylor’s To School Through the Fields, Tom Phelan’s We Were Rich and We Didn't Know It is a heartfelt and masterfully written memoir of growing up in Ireland in the 1940s. We Were Rich and We Didn't Know It recounts Tom’s upbringing in an isolated, rural community from the day he was delivered by the local midwife. With tears and laughter, it speaks to the strength of the human spirit in the face of life's adversities.
Auteur(s): Tom Phelan
-
Church of Lies
- Auteur(s): Flora Jessop, Paul T. Brown
- Narrateur(s): Eve Bianco
- Durée: 10 h et 36 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
"I was one of 28 children born to my dad and his three wives. Indoctrinated to believe that the outside world was evil, and that I resided among the righteous, I was destined to marry a man chosen for me by the Prophet. I would then live in harmony with my sister-wives, bear many children, and obey and serve my future husband in this life and throughout eternity. But my innocence didn't last long." Flora goes on from there to tell the dramatic true story of how she ultimately escaped and has been rescuing women and children from the FLDS.
Auteur(s): Flora Jessop, Autres
-
Born with Teeth
- A Memoir
- Auteur(s): Kate Mulgrew
- Narrateur(s): Kate Mulgrew
- Durée: 10 h et 40 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Audie Award, Narration by Author, 2016. Raised by unconventional Irish Catholics who knew "how to drink, how to dance, how to talk, and how to stir up the devil", Kate Mulgrew grew up with poetry and drama in her bones. But in her mother, a would-be artist burdened by the endless arrival of new babies, young Kate saw the consequences of a dream deferred.
-
-
This book is a Love Letter to Tim Hagan
- Écrit par Todd Herron le 2018-03-02
Auteur(s): Kate Mulgrew
-
Cult Insanity
- A Memoir of Polygamy, Prophets, and Blood Atonement
- Auteur(s): Irene Spencer
- Narrateur(s): Laural Merlington
- Durée: 10 h et 11 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
In Cult Insanity, Spencer reveals the outrageous behavior of her brother-in-law Ervil---a self-proclaimed prophet who determined he was called to set the house of God in order---and how he terrorized their colony. Claiming to be God's avenger and to have a license to kill in the name of God, Ervil ordered the murders of friends and family members, eliminating all those who challenged his authority. Cult Insanity is a riveting, terrifying memoir of polygamist life under the tyranny of a madman.
Auteur(s): Irene Spencer
-
My Mother, Munchausen's and Me
- A True Story of Betrayal and a Shocking Family Secret
- Auteur(s): Helen Naylor
- Narrateur(s): Helen Naylor
- Durée: 10 h et 15 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Ten years ago, Helen Naylor discovered her mother, Elinor, had been faking debilitating illnesses for 30 years. After Elinor’s self-induced death, Helen found her diaries, which Elinor wrote daily for more than 50 years. The diaries reveal not only the inner workings of Elinor’s twisted mind and self-delusion, but also shocking revelations about Helen’s childhood. Everything Helen knew about herself and her upbringing was founded on a lie.
Auteur(s): Helen Naylor
-
American Daughter
- A Memoir
- Auteur(s): Stephanie Thornton Plymale, Elissa Wald
- Narrateur(s): Mozhan Marno
- Durée: 9 h et 5 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
The sharp and surprising true story of a woman who finally sets out to understand her past, and the mother she had one day hoped to forget. Full of unexpected twists and unbelievable revelations, American Daughter is an immersive memoir that will have you on the edge of your seat to the very last minute.
Auteur(s): Stephanie Thornton Plymale, Autres
-
Silent Sisters
- A True Story
- Auteur(s): Joanne Lee, Ann Cusack
- Narrateur(s): Melanie Crawley
- Durée: 8 h et 28 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Growing up, Joanne suffered at the hands of a violent boyfriend and controlling relatives, as her mother lapsed into a downward spiral following the break-up of her marriage. But the consequences of her mother's lifestyle turned out to be worse than Joanne could ever have imagined. She already knew about the baby buried in a shallow makeshift grave next to the family plot. But when Joanne came across a red plastic bin in her mother's wardrobe in 2009, she realised that the family home held an even more sinister secret.
-
-
incredible read
- Écrit par Kelly Gregoire/Fitzpatrick le 2022-04-25
Auteur(s): Joanne Lee, Autres
-
Favorite Wife
- Escape from Polygamy
- Auteur(s): Susan Ray Schmidt
- Narrateur(s): Susan Ericksen
- Durée: 22 h et 1 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
She had no choice in the matter - none of the girls did. Her mission was to give birth to and raise many children in devoted service to a shared husband. Susan was 15 years old when she became the sixth wife of Verlan LeBaron, one of the leaders of a rogue Mormon cult, who was engaged in a blood feud with his brother that from 1972 to 1988 claimed up to two dozen lives. In this gripping and eloquent book, Susan Ray Schmidt tells the story of growing up on the inside and of her ultimate escape with her children from an oppressive and violent life.
Auteur(s): Susan Ray Schmidt
-
Damaged: The Heartbreaking True Story of a Forgotten Child
- Auteur(s): Cathy Glass
- Narrateur(s): Denica Fairman
- Durée: 8 h et 41 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Although Jodie is only eight years old, she is violent, aggressive, and has already been through numerous foster families. Her last hope is Cathy Glass. At the Social Services office, Cathy (an experienced foster carer) is pressured into taking Jodie as a new placement. Jodie's challenging behaviour has seen off five carers in four months. Despite her reservations, Cathy decides to take on Jodie to protect her from being placed in an institution.
-
-
touching
- Écrit par Amazon Customer le 2019-04-26
Auteur(s): Cathy Glass
-
The Hospital
- Auteur(s): Barbara O'Hare
- Narrateur(s): Charlie Sanderson
- Durée: 8 h et 43 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Barbara was 12 when she was admitted to the psychiatric hospital Aston Hall in 1971. From a troubled home, she'd hoped she would find sanctuary there. But during her stay, Barbara was systematically drugged and abused by its head physician, Dr Kenneth Milner. Somehow, eventually, she started to campaign for answers. This is a shocking account of how vulnerable children were preyed upon by the doctor entrusted with their care.
-
-
What a fighter
- Écrit par B.J Snider le 2020-06-19
Auteur(s): Barbara O'Hare
-
The Girls with No Names
- Auteur(s): Serena Burdick
- Narrateur(s): Emily Lawrence, Nancy Peterson, Amy McFadden
- Durée: 12 h et 24 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Growing up in New York City in the 1910s, Luella and Effie Tildon realize that even as wealthy young women, their freedoms come with limits. But when the sisters discover a shocking secret about their father, Luella, the brazen elder sister, becomes emboldened to do as she pleases. Her rebellion comes with consequences, and one morning Luella is mysteriously gone.
-
-
Couldn’t finish it
- Écrit par Nicol Tuck le 2021-01-08
Auteur(s): Serena Burdick
-
Breaking Free
- How I Escaped Polygamy, the FLDS Cult, and My Father, Warren Jeffs
- Auteur(s): Rachel Jeffs
- Narrateur(s): Rachel Jeffs
- Durée: 8 h et 3 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
In this searing memoir of survival in the spirit of Stolen Innocence, the daughter of Warren Jeffs, the self-proclaimed Prophet of the FLDS Church, takes you deep inside the secretive polygamist Mormon fundamentalist cult run by her family and how she escaped it. Born into the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, Rachel Jeffs was raised in a strict patriarchal culture defined by subordinate sister wives and men they must obey.
-
-
Fascinating and Gribbing!
- Écrit par Sue Volpe le 2017-11-28
Auteur(s): Rachel Jeffs
-
North of Normal
- A Memoir of My Wilderness Childhood, My Unusual Family, and How I Survived Both
- Auteur(s): Cea Sunrise Person
- Narrateur(s): Cea Sunrise Person
- Durée: 9 h et 33 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Sex, drugs, and...bug stew? In the vein of The Glass Castle and Wild, Cea Sunrise Person's compelling memoir of a childhood spent with her dysfunctional counter-culture family in the Canadian wilderness - a searing story of physical, emotional, and psychological survival.
-
-
A good story
- Écrit par Utilisateur anonyme le 2020-05-28
Auteur(s): Cea Sunrise Person
-
Everything Is Fine
- A Memoir
- Auteur(s): Vince Granata
- Narrateur(s): Sean Patrick Hopkins
- Durée: 8 h et 37 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Vince Granata remembers standing in front of his suburban home in Connecticut the day his mother and father returned from the hospital with his three new siblings in tow. He had just finished scrawling their names in orange chalk on the driveway: Christopher, Timothy, and Elizabeth. Twenty-three years later, Vince was a thousand miles away when he received the news that would change his life - his younger brother, Tim, propelled by unchecked schizophrenia, had killed their mother in their childhood home.
Auteur(s): Vince Granata
-
Stolen Innocence
- My Story of Growing Up in a Polygamous Sect, Becoming a Teenage Bride, and Breaking Free of Warren Jeffs
- Auteur(s): Elissa Wall, Lisa Pulitzer
- Narrateur(s): Renée Raudman
- Durée: 15 h et 50 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
In September 2007, Elissa Wall, the star witness against polygamous sect leader Warren Jeffs, gave captivating testimony of how Jeffs forced her to marry her first cousin at age 14. This harrowing account proved to be the most compelling evidence against Jeffs, showing the harsh realities of this closed community and the lengths to which Jeffs went in order to control the sect's women. Now, in this courageous memoir, Wall tells the incredible story of how she emerged from the confines of the Fundamentalist Church of Latter Day Saints and helped bring one of America's most notorious criminals to justice.
-
-
Heart wrenching tough read.
- Écrit par Adele le 2020-08-14
Auteur(s): Elissa Wall, Autres
-
A Stolen Life
- A Memoir
- Auteur(s): Jaycee Dugard
- Narrateur(s): Jaycee Dugard
- Durée: 7 h et 30 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
"In the summer of 1991 I was a normal kid. I did normal things. I had friends and a mother who loved me. I was just like you. Until the day my life was stolen. For eighteen years I was a prisoner. I was an object for someone to use and abuse. For eighteen years I was not allowed to speak my own name. I became a mother and was forced to be a sister. For eighteen years I survived an impossible situation. On August 26, 2009, I took my name back. My name is Jaycee Lee Dugard. I dont think of myself as a victim. I survived...."
-
-
Eye opening
- Écrit par Cynthia Poirier le 2018-07-20
Auteur(s): Jaycee Dugard
-
Sex Cult Nun
- Breaking Away from the Children of God, a Wild, Radical Religious Cult
- Auteur(s): Faith Jones
- Narrateur(s): Jaime Lamchick
- Durée: 13 h et 11 min
- Version intégrale
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
Educated meets The Vow in this story of liberation and self-empowerment - an inspiring and stranger-than-fiction memoir of growing up in and breaking free from the Children of God, an oppressive, extremist religious cult.
Auteur(s): Faith Jones
Description
"The narration by Wariner compliments the candid nature of her story...A captivating and emotional story delivered in a straightforward way without an ounce of self-pity." (Library Journal)
A riveting, deeply-affecting audiobook memoir of one girl's coming-of-age experiences in a polygamist cult.
Ruth Wariner was the 39th of her father's 42 children. Growing up on a farm in rural Mexico, where authorities turned a blind eye to the practices of her community, Ruth lives in a ramshackle house without indoor plumbing or electricity. At church, preachers teach that God will punish the wicked by destroying the world and that women can only ascend to Heaven by entering into polygamous marriages and giving birth to as many children as possible. After Ruth's father - the man who had been the founding prophet of the colony - is brutally murdered by his brother in a bid for church power, her mother remarries, becoming the second wife of another faithful congregant.
In need of government assistance and supplemental income, Ruth and her siblings are carted back and forth between Mexico and the United States, where her mother collects welfare and her step-father works a variety of odd jobs. Ruth comes to love the time she spends in the States, realizing that perhaps the community into which she was born is not the right one for her. As Ruth begins to doubt her family's beliefs and question her mother's choices, she struggles to balance her fierce love for her siblings with her determination to forge a better life for herself.
Recounted from the innocent and hopeful perspective of a child, The Sound of Gravel is the remarkable true story of a girl fighting for peace and love. This is an intimate, gripping audiobook resonant with triumph, courage, and resilience.
Ce que les auditeurs disent de The Sound of Gravel
Moyenne des évaluations de clientsÉvaluations – Cliquez sur les onglets pour changer la source des évaluations.
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Tinitree
- 2022-05-08
Engaging story
I really enjoyed this book. Raw without being too disturbing. I looked forward to continuing to listen. Recommended.
-
Au global
- Blushingbride
- 2022-04-30
Could not stop!
Wow what a riveting story of ones journey through horrific abuse. I was captivated!
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- T
- 2021-05-05
Great book!
Amazing how one cannot see how their behaviour impacts the lives of others. Tragic and remarkable!
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Shelby S.
- 2021-03-20
Months later, I still think of this story
An incredible story that had me feeling every emotion. At the end, I mainly feel proud of this woman. What an accomplishment to survive the life she was forced to endure and I am so thankful you shared your story with us, Ruth.
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Anonymous User
- 2020-05-09
Heart Wrenching
heart wrenching. beautifully written. couldnt put it down. ruth is a wonderful story teller.
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Lesley A.
- 2016-01-16
Unputdownable
The Sound of Gravel is truly a gripping story that has you invested in the storyline and the characters; angry, sad and joyous on their behalves. I LOVED hearing it in Ruth's own voice!
24 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Brenda
- 2016-04-29
Excellent read
The author read the book which made this story even better. What Ms Wariner went through was heart breaking but how she survived is inspirational. I listen to books while I walk. I found myself eager to get out for my walk so that I could listen to the story.
17 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Melanie Kay Haering
- 2016-03-03
Excellent--such a common story among polygamist
Would you listen to The Sound of Gravel again? Why?
No, I would recommend it however
Who was your favorite character and why?
The main character Ruth--her perseverance and her voice
What about Ruth Wariner’s performance did you like?
Its her own account
Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?
Yes
Any additional comments?
Very insightful and sad at the same time. I'm glad that she escaped with some sense of normalcy
12 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Shannon Eagle
- 2016-04-17
Chilling
So chilling to hear the story from the mouth of the woman who lived and survived this horrible story.... Well written dialogue and attention to detail; it is loving, hopeful and maddeningly tragic..... Can't stop listening, be prepared to binge on it because you have to know what happens next.
9 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- gina
- 2016-05-20
the sad truth of polygamy
Love it . I have been reading a ton of these polygamy book can't understand why these women stay. well I guess I can. fear and brain wash. I wish our government would do more to help these young girls
7 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Angela Ryan
- 2018-09-29
Narration is the problem
I purchased this book on Audible after reading the many glowing reviews. I have a 2 hour commute to and from work daily and getting lost in a book helps me de-stress after a long day. I could not, however, get past chapter 5. The author narrates her own book. Her voice is so monotone and she reads so rapid fire in places that I just stopped listening. There is zero emotion in her voice that is conveyed to the listener. I found my mind drifting off and having to rewind back to a familiar spot. I feel like I'm back in grammar school and the teacher is asking a fellow student to read aloud. I really wanted to enjoy this book. So disappointing!
5 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Lindsay
- 2018-04-18
Talk about intense
Where does The Sound of Gravel rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?
This book is definitely up there, especially among the memoirs. Ruth's story is so different and had me hooked in from the start!
What did you like best about this story?
What I loved best about the book was Ruth's resilience. Even when everything was as harder than I could have ever imagined, she never gave up. Her story is absolutely inspiring.
What does Ruth Wariner bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
Ruth's narration isn't anything unique, but it is nice to hear her story in her voice.
Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?
I was in tears when we got to the part where the title of the book makes sense. The story is so emotional and tense and you can't help but be moved along with it.
Any additional comments?
Amazing memoir, but not a light read.
5 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Michelle
- 2016-08-08
Sometimes the bad guy gets away
Halfway through this book it dawned on me that I was not reading a novel with a made up story and a hero at the end. That no matter what the end, the monsters in this story could still be out there, not caught by a hero or heroine. This is a heartbreaking tale, a type of life still lived by many. I wanted to jump in this book and save the helpless, kick the monsters ass and bring them to justice. Very well written. Would love a part two to this.
5 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Wendy
- 2016-03-26
Gripping....
A real page turner! This compelling story shares the life of the author, born and raised in a polygamist community. Her father was murdered when she was 3, and her mother married an abusing, neglectful man. Ruth's childhood was sapped in the toils of housework, raising her younger siblings and caring for her mother, a woman emotionally crippled by the neglect of her husband. But all was not dire, for Ruth found her way to extricate herself, raised her younger sisters, and completed college. I only wish she had gotten out sooner and filed charges against her abuser.
4 les gens ont trouvé cela utile
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Jennifer E Lewis
- 2016-01-16
Amazing!
It's been a long time since a nonfiction book has moved me so much. I am left, literally, speechless. An incredible story.
14 les gens ont trouvé cela utile