The chaos starts before the intro even finishes as Amanda, Tyler, James, and their favorite guest Arson each take a turn doing the opening—who nailed it (or failed spectacularly)? Arson dives headfirst into his first case as Tyler’s lawyer, James gives a very neck-y update, and Arson also reveals he’s fully embracing his ‘Unc phase.’ Amanda drops a list of hilariously named Scottish snowplows, then challenges the boys to a game of What’s That Song?, where chaos, bad guesses, and brain-dead moments are guaranteed. Hold on tight—it’s a ride you won’t forget!

Amanda opens the episode with a joke that sets the tone before the trio takes a trip back to the early days of social media and all the chaos that came with it. Things escalate quickly when Amanda shares an FML so unhinged it turns into a collective ‘WTF,’ James drags everyone down a Reddit spiral, and another rock showdown manages to irritate James yet again. Somewhere between learning questionable facts about pyramids and hearing a story that raises a very important question—Mangoose, do you fear it?—the episode fully embraces its brain dead destiny.

James kicks things off with a joke that sets the tone, then Amanda recounts a recent run-in with The Bad that immediately raises concerns about Tyler needing a lawyer. AI shows up purely to roast James, Amanda launches into a mini game rant, and the group discovers why James is—once again—in pain. Things wrap up with a surprisingly deep question: if you only had one round-trip in a time machine, how badly would you mess up the timeline? It’s chaotic, speculative, and full of advice you should absolutely not take.

The new year starts exactly how you’d expect—with absolutely no adult supervision. Amanda, Tyler, and James are joined by Arson to debate whether Amanda completely botched the intro, revisit some late Christmas content, and unveil a surprise that sends the group spiraling. The infamous Christmas curse refuses to stay in December as bad internet connections cause panic and prove what happens when the teacher leaves the room unattended. Somewhere along the way, the gang tries (and fails) to pinpoint the exact moment this show went off the rails. New year, same chaos, zero control.

It’s a full-on Brain Dead Christmas as Amanda, Tyler, and James are joined by their favorite festive troublemaker, Arson. Tyler kicks things off by explaining why Iceland might be the most generous Nordic nation, Amanda takes aim at a certain Christmas song, and the gang dives into some truly odd holiday traditions. Tyler somehow ends up transporting everything from food to toilets, James hosts a Christmas movie showdown, and—because it wouldn’t be December without it—the Christmas curse makes its dramatic return. Add in Fear Factor nostalgia, earbud chaos, behind-the-scenes scheming, and Tyler’s surprisingly ambitious coffee shop dream, and you’ve got a holiday episode packed with chaos, laughs, and questionable ideas. Merry Brain Dead Christmas.

In this pre-Christmas whirlwind, Amanda, Tyler, and James dive straight into holiday nonsense with a steak debate no one asked for but everyone will judge. Amanda unveils her elite 2025 Christmas wish list, James drops major news for Scotland’s football fans, and the trio finally taste-test the questionable festive snacks from last week. Chips vs. crisps sparks an international incident, Amanda presents a list that might confirm Tyler is actually a dog, Christmas treats for pets get weird, Tyler tells a joke that… happens, and Amanda closes things out with a mind-bending question that derails what was left of the conversation. Merry chaos to all.

The brain cells were already low when the episode started—then they gave up entirely. Amanda and Tyler share the emotional rollercoaster of parenting a 9-year-old, James brings in a batch of festive-flavored foods straight from someone’s personal hell, and a Call of Duty rant erupts over a game release nobody knew even happened. The Lees make a surprise comeback, the trio debates sports they wish they’d tried (or survived), Amanda dives into Chuck E. Cheese nostalgia and a completely unhinged Road Runner theory, and everything wraps with family photo trauma and wardrobe malfunctions. It’s the holiday gift you didn’t ask for but absolutely needed.

December kicks off with a much-needed Christmas music alarm warning—and Tyler delivers it with unnecessary enthusiasm. James and Amanda immediately dive into a heated debate over whose Christmas music taste is the real crime, Amanda unveils a fresh list of dog breeds for judgment, and James finally drops the punchline to the joke he’s been dragging out for weeks. The trio recaps Amanda and Tyler’s chaotic date night, Amanda vents about The Mummy 4, and she and James hype up an upcoming show like it’s the second coming. Everything wraps with Tyler unleashing a collection of thoughts that absolutely never needed to be shared. Peak festive brain dead energy.