Alice Hoffman Never Disappoints

When the movie Practical Magic was released, I was delighted with the story line. I appreciated the relationship of sisters, the pain of unrequited Love, and the message that women could help themselves and were strongest when assembled.

Rules of Magic was FABULOUS; taking the reader through the tail end of the baby boomer era, illustrating self discovery, the futility of ignoring who one truly is, the cruelty of a constantly critical society.

When I heard Magic Lessons was on its way, I wasted no time in pre-ordering and within hours of receiving it, I listened to the entire book. Maria!! A legend 'brought to life.' Once again Alice Hoffman paints a world of women who are dedicated to their own; strong enough to withstand harsh societal oppression and persecution - truly acquainted with the rule of cause and effect. From their romantic lives to their familiars, from innate talent to acquired -- the journey of these women is both inspiring and a cautionary tale. Having listened to this only once so far, you can bet I'll be listening again -- And will be investing in a hard copy for my library. Love these Owens women!!! Thank you Alice Hoffman.

PS - Besides this trilogy, The Probably Future, Seventh Heaven, The Red Garden, are equally worthwhile. So grateful for this prolific author as I continue to read her works!

31 people found this helpful

Disappointing

Just a very stupid love story with herbal magic recipes. I gave up after a couple of hours. I loved other Alice Hoffman books but this one reminded me of a paperback romance novel.

12 people found this helpful

Disappointing--Probably better if read hardcopy

Finished it. The plot definitely picked up on the second half. This book could have benefited from better editing efforts and definitely a better narrator, as Sutton consistently detracted from the story and never improved the experience. If you are a fan of the Owens women and their stories, you get small tidbits to fill in the back story...too much repetition and just not enough substance for my taste. My advice is to read the book rather than listen to the AB. Following is my experience as I read it...

Listening to the dialog of women in the 1600s with a contemporary, and obnoxious, American accent is off-putting at best and takes you right out of the story at worst. This is part of the magic of a period piece especially one we can HEAR. Also off-putting when the narrator varies between a flat affect where not appropriate (see below) and a strange halted sing-song rhythm like one would use when reading to a child. Had I listened to the sample, I would not have bought this as an audiobook; sadly, I preordered.

Update: Half way through and the story has improved, though remains far too close to a romance novel for my taste. More magic, less romance would have been a better recipe. Flat and insipid narration is making this listen a chore. Don't get me started on the pronunciation of foreign languages-especially, some of which I speak, just dreadful. Perhaps this story would benefit from being read rather than listened to. Will revise if/when I finish.

11 people found this helpful

This

If you've followed the Owens women and their saga through the previous volumes then this book is for you. It is everything I wanted it to be, a little personal gift from one of my favorite authors.

The straightforward narration tells the story as if read from journals. No excess emotion is given to the words. They are allowed to stand on their own.

Loved it.

7 people found this helpful

Lots of repetition

The book could have been ~25 pages shorter with a better editor. Lists of remedies with every location were expected, if unnecessary. Rules about getting back what you give every time a character uses magic were tedious. Rules about familiars every time an animal is mentioned were just obnoxious. I (and Sutton Foster, I suspect) could have done without the "songs."

Sutton Foster did a good job with the reading. Pace was appropriately meandering, as one expects with this sort of novel.

The story itself was okay. I enjoyed the culinary stuff more than the herbal stuff. I liked it better than some of her books, but I think I will pass on Hoffman in the future.

6 people found this helpful

Meh

The story just wasn't captivating. About halfway through, I just wanted it to end so I could move on to a better book. I did finish it because I just need to finish books once I start them. Wasn't a bad book, but it got hard to pay attention after a while. I wasn't really invested in the characters.

5 people found this helpful

Get this book.

Sutton Foster is an outstanding narrator. Alice Hoffman has done it again. Get the book.

5 people found this helpful

beautiful, and keeps you engaged. descriptive

such a beautifully well written book. much based on history. historical accounting along with a magical story

2 people found this helpful

Captivating!

Wonderful story with many life lessons and I didn't want to stop listening or they story to end.

2 people found this helpful

Loved this book!

I couldn’t wait to listen to it on my daily commute. I feel like I know the characters personally and can completely relate to their emotions!
Now on to the next in the series!
❤️💔🖤❤️