Prom is approaching, and Jeremy has his eye on Amanda. Well, every guy has his eye on Amanda, and a few of the girls too. She’s the hottest girl in school, so Jeremy doesn’t actually think he has a shot.

That is, until he meets Lilly in the back stairwell during his spare one afternoon. She’s drawn a pentagram on the floor with lipstick, and she’s reading from some heavy latin tome. She seems to think that she’s a witch, and Jeremy would normally burst into a fit of laughter—but he saw something that he couldn’t quite explain: a glowing light that grew brighter and brighter in the middle of that pentagram, but there was no light source.

He’s open-minded, and Lilly has a spell in her book that can supposedly make any girl fall in love with the caster. The spell only requires some personal belonging from the female target. Jeremy manages to snag a pair of Amanda’s undies from girls’ changing room, and then Lilly carries out the enchantment.

The spell seems to be working, but there’s a catch: for the magic to keep working, Jeremy has to keep in direct contact with the enchanted undies. There’s only one easy way to make sure he’s always touching them....

There’s just one little problem. Lilly’s no expert in latin, and she may have accidentally read out two spells instead of one when she was enchanting the stolen undies.