IT WOULD. NOT. ENDDDD....

I bought this because I truly enjoyed the Nightingale, I made a mistake.
There is no doubt that Kristin Hannah is a beautiful writer capable of making one feel like they are transported to a different place and time. But this book was excruciating to get through.

1) It’s very violent, and it’s all directed toward women. Its not that I can’t abide violence for the sake of telling a story honestly....but this is 15 long hours of the same violence over and over annnd over again!
2) Though I know that many battered women behave just the way that Cora did... it would’ve been more bearable/understandable had this book been at least 5 hours shorter! Instead, after many chapters with the same scenario on loop...the reader becomes absolutely fed up with (what most people would perceive to be) Cora’s moronic behavior and lack of regard for her daughters safety.
3) I now thoroughly detest the endearment “Baby Girl”.... I think I heard it 3,000 times.
4) For the most part, Julia Whelan is a gifted narrator. There’s just one thing that bothers me... every male that she voices sounds like a 70 year old miner, no matter what the age of the character is.

Wish I hadn’t used a credit.

39 people found this helpful

✫✫✫✫✫ 5 Stars ✫✫✫✫✫

I don't even know where to begin to explain how much I loved this book or how it left me emotionally. This book is hard because it deals with PTSD and domestic violence but it is so much more. It is about a mother/daughter relationship, it is about unconditional love and it is about learning to adapt and for me especially this book is about true love even if this isn't a romance.

Set in Alaska in the 1970's, we get a true feeling of what it was like to live "off the grid" and of the land but still have community and family. It also gives us a feel for what it must have been like for Vietnam survivors with PTSD in a world where PTSD didn't exist yet. This is a story about a family with a dad with PTSD, a mom who loves her husband and remembers what he was like before the war and a young daughter caught up in a life that was anything she could have expected. Leni (the daughter) is the protagonist of this story, she goes from 13 to about 25 over the course of this book and we get to she her blossom and harden from life in Alaska. She finds true love and she has a dream and then its all ripped away. Seeing how she grows and makes the best with the life she has and the beautiful undying strength of the relationship she has with her mother melted my heart. Without giving actual spoilers, I'll just say this book made me mad, broke my heart, had me cheering like a cheerleader, made me proud and melted my heart. Every emotion I could have in a book.... they were all there in this one book. I highly recommend it!

The narration was superb! Julia Whelan completely brought this book to life, she gave each character their own voice and let me get lost in the story. PERFECT casting choice in my opinion!

#BestBook2018 #ChangedMyLife #AlaskaLife #Tagsgiving #Sweepstakes

97 people found this helpful

don't bother. predictable. narration irritating

very difficult to listen to. You can predict the setup, the behavior of characters and the irritation in the narration I couldn't listen too much longer. I sent it back

12 people found this helpful

A Long, Hard Slog Through Endless Despair and Heartache

I really wanted to like this book. The writing was excellent, technically. But it was just ONE BAD THING AFTER ANOTHER for these characters. There was NO LETTING UP, no comic relief to break the tension, no happy moments in between all the horror and terror and death and despair.

I don't usually write reviews. But I had to warn people. I also don't usually read contemporary adult fiction. So maybe it's all like this; I don't know. However, if it is, I have no further desire to read any. B I'm going to compare this book briefly with another book that had a lot of heartache and despair, "Birds Without Wings" by Louis Something I Can't Remember. He also wrote "Corelli's Mandoline". Another book with heartache. But somehow, these books had redeeming features and humor and characters you could like and root for.

In "The Great Alone", it's like watching a horrible train wreck in slow motion...you know every little thing that is going to happen WAY before it actually happens, but you're powerless to stop it and somehow you can't look away. I guess I was hoping the author WOULD have a little more imagination, and maybe NOT take the most expected path to every tragic conclusion, but -SPOILER ALERT- she doesn't, and she does. You pretty much listen for a few chapters and you know EXACTLY what's going to happen to almost everyone. By the middle of the book, I could have written the epilogue and been 99% correct, even down to minute details.

The author clearly knows and loves Alaska well, and it shows. Having lived there myself, I can attest to the authenticity of the descriptions and vocabulary. But I just couldn't handle the endless grief with no break. And the unbearably heavy-handed foreshadowing that pretty much gave away the entire plot.

I'm sure professional critics will love this book. It's well written and very depressing, and since that what they seem to go for in adult fiction, the author has a winning combination. I don't think I'll get another one by her, though.

The narrator does a STELLAR job. She's probably the reason I kept listening long after I knew everything would play out the way it did, and she's the reason my review gave as many stars as it did. I would get another book read by this narrator in a NEW YORK MINUTE, which is WAY faster than an Alaska minute, or so I'm told.

265 people found this helpful

Shocked By The High Ratings ...

This story was so annoyingly unrealistic that it bordered on insulting. With the exception of Marge, Tom and Matthew, there were no likable characters. "Mama" was a co-conspirator of child abuse who chose her own selfish obsession over her daughter. And the daughter - Lenny - heralded her selfish mother as some sort of saint in the end. I still have 20 minutes to go, but decided that I had painstakingly heard enough.

10 people found this helpful

Riveting!

I have never read anything by this author before; the review sounded interesting, but what drew me was the narrator. I love Julia Whelan! I have mixed feelings about the story. The author captured my attention with her descriptions of Alaska, and what it would be like to move there. Since I work in the field of Domestic Violence, it was hard to listen to this story at times. Thankfully, we have come a long way in helping victims/survivors of DV. Once I started listening to The Great Alone, I was hooked. I wanted to listen straight through. It’s been a long time since I stayed up half the night, consumed by a book! I shall be reading more by Kristin Hannah, I’m sure. What a story!

234 people found this helpful

Such a talented author and narrator...

I recently read The Nightingale... and loved it to pieces. So I bumped this book by the same author to the top of my list when it came out. The books are so different, only the beautiful writing feels familiar. Kristin Hannah took me right into this family, their move and the new community in rural Alaska they joined.
I could see the train wreck coming for hours but couldn't look away and couldn't stop listening until the book was over... have to admit I cried. This won't have the universal appeal that The Nightingale had, my husband wouldn't listen to such a relationship oriented book and domestic violence is just a plain old hard topic. However, I found it's message of the power of community, friendship, family and the resilience of the human spirit to be uplifting. Made me wish I was Alaska tough... like the characters I met in this book.

229 people found this helpful

Very disappointing

I don't understand all the rave reviews. I always look forward to Kristin Hannah's books and loved The Nightengale. This book just meandered and seem to go nowhere with the story except forward in time. I don't want to give spoilers, but I kept waiting for something to happen. I found the characters cliched and stereotypical and just lost patience.

16 people found this helpful

Couldn’t finish it.....

I love this author and I’ve read most everything she’s written. Bought this without a second thought. Really disappointed. Kept waiting for the story to get better but it just went on and on repeating the same scenarios. Very predictable and very disturbing. Had no idea I was wading into a story about domestic abuse. That’s on me. I’ll be better at reading the synopsis of a new book despite it being by a beloved author.

23 people found this helpful

Not my favorite by this author

Would you try another book from Kristin Hannah and/or Julia Whelan?

I have read and enjoyed every other book by Kristin Hannah, and this is not up to par. I did think the narrator was excellent.

Would you be willing to try another book from Kristin Hannah? Why or why not?

Yes, I will look forward to her next project.

If this book were a movie would you go see it?

It would take a couple of hours to sit through the movie. The book goes on and on and on.

Any additional comments?

The characters were all written sympathetically and I'm sure it gave an unvarnished truth about domestic abuse, but that was part of the problem. I found myself continually frustrated by the refusal of the abused wife and mother to do anything to help herself or her daughter. The frustration turned to fury about half way through, and still the story kept on and on, repeating and repeating. It engaged me to the point where I kept listening because I cared about the characters, but it was exhausting.

77 people found this helpful