In this episode of NY Giants Generations, we tackle one of the most debated questions in Giants and NFL history: Does Eli Manning truly belong in the Hall of Fame... or just the Hall of Good?

Eli's résumé is iconic—two Super Bowl rings, two Super Bowl MVPs, and the slayer of Tom Brady’s perfect season. But when you stack him up next to the elite quarterbacks of his era—Drew Brees, Ben Roethlisberger, Philip Rivers, and even Aaron Rodgers—does he really measure up?

We break it all down:

• The highs: Legendary playoff runs, clutch gene, and durability—never missing a start for over a decade.
• The lows: A career .500 record, 244 interceptions, and seasons where he barely cracked the top 15 in passer rating.
• The context: How playing in New York and winning big games impacted the legacy.
• The numbers: Comparing Eli's stats directly to Brees, Big Ben, and Rivers—with eye-popping results.

Plus, we hear from analysts, fans, and former teammates who weigh in on the myth and reality of Eli's career. Is he a generational winner whose intangibles outweigh his stats—or a good quarterback who got hot at the right time?

Whether you're riding the Eli4Canton train or believe he's a product of two magical playoff runs, this episode will give you everything you need to argue your side with confidence.

Subscribe now and join the Big Blue debate as we ask: Eli Manning—Hall of Fame… or Hall of Good?

#newyorkgiants #nygiants #nfl