Send us a text

What makes a cozy mystery click—and when does it fall flat? In this week’s episode, Eric and Andrea dive deep into Private Eyes Season 2, Episodes 10 through 18, unpacking the highs, lows, and surprising twists of the back half of the season. From boxing rings and medieval fairs to octopus capers and suburban sleuthing, the duo shares candid takes on what worked, what dragged, and which episodes left them wanting more.

Along the way, they spotlight familiar Hallmark faces, compare standout mysteries to other fan favorites like Murder, She Wrote and Diagnosis Murder, and debate which episodes deserve a cozy rewatch. If you’re a fan of Hallmark Mysteries, Hallmark Channel favorites, or just love a good Cozy Mystery binge, this review is packed with insights, laughs, and a few unexpected confessions.

Highlights from this episode:

Why the boxing-themed episode was a knockout miss for both hosts

• The unexpected charm of an octopus-led mystery in “Finding Leroy”
• Guest star sightings: Hallmark favorites popping up in surprising roles
• A twisty season finale that sets up Season 3 with shocking reveals
• Which episodes kept us glued to the screen—and which had us reaching for our phones

Press play to join the conversation, and don’t forget to subscribe for more Hallmark Mysteries reviews, previews, and cozy mystery deep dives every week!

Follow us on social media:
Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
Youtube

Or visit our website.

This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

Send us a text

What happens when Hallmark Mysteries takes its most divisive franchise back to the island? In this episode, Eric and Andrea dive into Mystery Island: House Rules, the latest installment in the cozy yet controversial series. From the surprising “was it all just a game?” twist to standout performances and directorial choices that gave the film a fresh vibe, we’re breaking down everything that worked—and what still fell flat.

Expect lively debate, honest reactions, and a few surprising comparisons (yes, even Clue and Death in Paradise make an appearance). Whether you loved it or loathed it, this review will give you plenty to think about before you press play on Hallmark+.

Highlights:

• Why House Rules stands out as the most fun entry in the Mystery Island series.
• A closer look at Clare Niederprum’s direction and how it elevated the setting.
• The big “murder game” twist—did it land or fall short?
• Romance, callbacks, and a few eyebrow-raising character moments.
• Fan poll reactions and how this film fits into the larger Hallmark Mysteries landscape.

If you’re a fan of Hallmark Channel, Hallmark Mysteries, or cozy mysteries in general, this episode is for you. Hit play now, subscribe for more reviews, and join the conversation with fellow sleuthers every week!

Follow us on social media:
Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
Youtube

Or visit our website.

This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

Send us a text

Step into Stratford-upon-Avon with us as we review Shakespeare & Hathaway: Private Investigators (Season 1), now streaming on Hallmark Plus. Eric and Andrea dive deep into this quirky British cozy mystery series, unpacking the standout episodes, character dynamics, and whether it earns a place alongside favorites like Rosemary & Thyme and The Coroner. Expect lively debate, surprising takes, and a few laughs along the way

In this episode, we cover:

• 🎭 How Frank Hathaway and Luella Shakespeare stack up against other Hallmark mystery duos
• 🕵️ Why Sebastian might just be the best sidekick in cozy TV
• 🪄 The magic, funeral homes, and wellness retreats that make Season 1 memorable
• 📺 Which episodes to skip, which to savor, and the surprising fan-favorite moments
• ⚖️ How the series balances humor, Shakespearean nods, and surprisingly heavy themes

Whether you’re a Hallmark Channel fan, a BritBox binge-watcher, or just love cozy mysteries with a twist, this review is packed with insights (and disagreements!) you won’t want to miss.

👉 Press play to hear the full review, and don’t forget to subscribe for more Hallmark Mysteries, Hallmark Movies, and cozy mystery coverage every week

Follow us on social media:
Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
Youtube

Or visit our website.

This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.