Send us a text

You Might Be A Madman: "Unmasking Evil: The Sinister Story of Herb Baumeister"

In this thrilling episode of 'You Might Be A Madman', host John Zap dives into the sinister life of Herb Baumeister, one of history's most chilling figures. Contestants Dave and Matt test their intuition and knowledge as they navigate through Herb’s bizarre and disturbing behaviors. From socially awkward beginnings to his chilling crimes, listeners are immersed in a game that blurs the line between sanity and madness. With intriguing questions and unexpected twists, discover if you think like a madman. Plus, enjoy humorous segments and quirky ads that lighten the mood of this dark journey. Tune in and play along!

00:00 Introduction and Disclaimer
00:21 Welcome to 'You Might Be a Madman'
01:30 Meet the Contestants
04:24 Today's Madman: Herb Baumeister
04:33 Herb's Early Life and Odd Behavior
06:27 First Question: The Car Choice
11:26 Herb's Career and Marriage
11:40 Marker
13:05 Second Question: Physical Embarrassment
17:27 Round Two Recap and Contestant Scores
18:00 Herb's Thrift Shop Success
18:51 Herb's Troubled Personal Life
19:37 Question Three: Poor Choices
23:12 Herb's Secret Life
23:48 Commercial Break: Shady Herb Dimmer
24:56 Round Four: Tony Harris and Herb's Double Life
27:18 Question Four: Tony's Onto You
32:04 Final Round: Herb's Downfall
33:50 Question Five: Disposing of the Bodies
38:08 Conclusion and Final Scores