Unique interdisciplinary music-history treatment

What did you love best about Music as a Mirror of History?

Greenberg's obvious command of both history and music, and the extensive research that informs his expertise. The interdisciplinary nature of the course is unique.

What other book might you compare Music as a Mirror of History to and why?

I'd suggest that Greenberg's "How to Listen to and Understand Great Music" (which I've listened through three times over the years) is somewhat similar, with that title emphasizing music and bringing in history, and "Music as a Mirror" emphasizing history and bringing in music.

What does Professor Robert Greenberg bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

This question may be better suited for actual audiobooks rather than Great Courses. That said, a helpful pdf booklet does accompany this course, and while Greenberg seems to follow it closely (I looked at the booklet only after finishing the course), he adds plenty of vintage Greenberg comments and metaphors, and additional musical and historical material which isn't in the notes.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

No, but this is not a criticism. This is not a book, per se, but a series of twenty-four lectures. Each lecture is entirely self-contained.

Any additional comments?

This course was interesting, and accomplished its purpose: "we’ll explore the ways in whichhistory inspired the creation of certain musical works—and how thoseworks interpreted and memorialized the history that inspired them" (p. 2 in the notes). Greenberg is clearly in his element(s) as he combines history and music in a most interesting interdisciplinary fashion.

I had purchased this course thinking that Greenberg would major a bit more on music as a mirror of philosophy -- that is, how music reflects the way of thinking that a composer embraces in the context of his larger culture, and how philosophical underpinnings contribute toward the music of a particular time and place differing from the music of another time and place. In actuality, Greenberg's "How to Listen to and Understand Great Music" seemed to give more attention to that particular point than this course, which instead emphasizes the way that particular historical events influence particular composers and musical compositions. This is by no means a failing of the course; I was incorrect in my expectations, in that the course is "Music as a Mirror OF HISTORY", not "of Philosophy". Greenberg definitively demonstrates that many musical compositions are historically rooted, and often (as Greenberg emphasizes in the course) motivated by war (see p. 9 in the notes).

I learned a good deal of history in this course. Greenberg is working with historical vignettes, of course, but often "goes deep" in giving a quite extensive historical context -- not just the historical context of the time a piece was written, but the historical backdrop that brought things to where they were when a piece was written. Among the bits and pieces I picked up that were interesting to me: I didn't know that "Columbia" (from Christopher Columbus) was used as the poetic name for the United States; I was unaware of Beethoven's love-hate attitude (if I could put it that way) toward Napoleon, the history of La Marseillaise, the financial severity of the Great Depression, and the difficulty non-Russians have in understanding the Russian mind. Musically, I heard Chopin's Revolutionary Etude with new ears (long familiarity had dulled its impact) and now understand a bit better just what an "etude" is; I was thrilled to discover Copland's Third Symphony; I gained a more accurate understanding of the circumstances behind Handel's Water Music; I finally can put some content to Wagner's The Ring. I'm motivated to do some research on the following, among other things: the antisemitism of Richard Wagner, and just how late in United States history that antisemitic laws were still on the books; the connections between Wagner's The Ring and Tolkien's Lord of the Rings; the history of Paris and of New Orleans; the African influence upon American music; Eleanor Roosevelt's role in encouraging musical progress during the Depression; Haydn as a Roman Catholic; the devastation of Poland by the Nazi regime; Dvorak as a "ringer" brought to the United States by Jeannette Meyer Thurber to found a distinctive American school of music. I was intrigued by Greenberg's discussion of the musical technique known as "pastiche," and would love to explore its intersection with the notion of intertextuality in literary works. I'm also motivated to listen to a number of the works which were excerpted or referred to in the course, such as Copland's Symphony No. 3 and Gorecki's Symphony No. 3. I list all of the above items to gesture at the broad reach of this course.

Greenberg is always an engaging lecturer. That said, the sometimes-lengthy sections of historical context did at times become a bit tedious and hard to follow. But Greenberg does an outstanding job in making a potentially dull subject much less dull.

The course notes accompanying the audio are excellent. The bibliography in the course notes is quite impressive, and even more remarkable is the extent to which Greenberg engages his sources. The bibliography is not just there for show.

I am a parent who is interested in providing musical education for my children. For others like me, who might consider supplementing their children's education with this course, I will note that this course does have a few instances of vulgarity (generally in quoted material) and sexual innuendo. The intended audience appears to be college and above.

72 people found this helpful

Prof. Greenberg could read a grocery list...

Any additional comments?

... and I would buy it. Though this was more history and less music than I expected, it is delightful. His portrayal of Verdi alone is worth the price of admission. I'm learning a lot of things I never knew before (about 3/4 through the series), and certainly hearing some composers I'd never heard of. As so often happens with many of my Audible purchases, this one is sending me running to Amazon to buy more books and music so I can explore more. And I certainly want to complete my Greenberg library. Fiendishly clever marketing? ;-)

10 people found this helpful

Understanding "unapproachable" Music by context

What does Professor Robert Greenberg bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Mr. Greenberg, as usual, delivers his course with enthusiasm for the topic, insight, the right amount of distance to the subject - and love for just any kind of music.
By putting the works into their respective historical context, he introduces yet another aspect of "understanding" (and through that, hopefully, appreciating) music that may otherwise seem "too strange". Like in his "history of music" course, where he takes the "student" by the hand and explains how to disect a composition, if one wants to "get it", here Mr. Greenberg shows the political, social and religious events that led composers to their works.

What I personally like is that Mr. Greenberg keeps a professional distance. He isn't afraid to point out that some compositions aren't great, just because a great name has been stuck to them.
(On the other hand, he does waste quite some time to praise achievements by Americans, that have nothing to do with music OR history, to some length - where some of those listed may well be argued about whether they actually were American-first ... but that's nit-picking ;-) )

Any additional comments?

The music "excerpts" in this course are very short and sometimes don't give an expression of the whole work. Introducing the works as such isn't the goal of this course, rather it is about a tour through various historic events or times and showing a way of approaching music that most of us, likely, aren't listening to every day.
If you are not interested in history, in the development of our "modern world" or in an artist's (composer's) way of dealing with personal experience, this course is not for you. If you are looking for "great music", this course is not for you. If you are looking for education in world-history, this course is not for you.

This course is for you, if you want to add a new perspective to the way you get into contact with music that you think you don't like.

8 people found this helpful

Very interesting

I'm a fan of both the great lectures and of Mr. Goldberg. In this series of lectures, he weaves fascinating backdrops of world history in with great compositional works. This is probably more interesting for a history buff than a music enthusiast. I happen to be both. I enjoyed every minute of this.

5 people found this helpful

fabulous!

Professor Robert Greenberg can be an acquired taste but once acquired he is humorous and enthusiastic with subject matter that needs that approach or it might be depressing. Will definitely listen to more of his work!

5 people found this helpful

Thoroughly informative and entertaining

Very interesting lectures with extensive historical backgrounds which gives the listener a unique opportunity to hear the music in a very different, much more authentic way. I absolutely enjoyed this!

3 people found this helpful

Splendid

Among the Prof. Greenberg lectures, this one is the best. Must read every music fun as well as history lover

2 people found this helpful

Outstanding

A sweeping overview of Western history that covers the last 400 years. The relationship and historical context of each musical selection and it's composer to their time and place is clearly and convincingly demonstrated, using primary historical sources and first-rate musical examples. The result is a powerful perspective and commentary on the last several centuries of Western Civilization, and is particularly relevant today in 2016. Great course!

2 people found this helpful

Fascinating!

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

Highly recommended to anyone who loves to know the historical context in which music was written.

Any additional comments?

Professor Greenberg embraces teaching as a performance art and it is one of the reasons I love his courses. He said at the beginning that this was as much about history as music - I would respectfully disagree and say it was more about history than music. Initially that disappointed me, but I grew to appreciate the historical context described so much that I wouldn't have had it any other way! I learned about a composer new to me, Górecki, and so loved the excerpts of his Symphony of Sorrowful Songs that I purchased it. But I wouldn't have fallen so in love with it, had I not known the history to which it responded and the poem on which it was based.

4 people found this helpful

Decent But A Bit Distracted

An interesting course that highlighted several composers I was unaware of, and even one or two unknown (to me) works from composers that I had heard of. Having said that, I was disappointed that the course started in the Tudor period and raced quickly on. The good and bad thing about the course is that it assumes you know nothing about the period relevant to the lecture at hand. This sometimes unfortunately leads to some lectures that are 80% history, 20% music. Though delivered with an informed verve, a number of the lessons just seem to wander down off topic sidebars and lack a coherent narrative thread. It was great to get some context for some faves and to be introduced to some new compelling pieces and composers, I'd have to say the other 'great courses' by Professor Greenberg I've heard so far are more organized and enjoyable.

1 person found this helpful