A lengthy but intriguing look at the English

This book endeavors to cover the entire history of England. From its earliest years under Rome prior to Saxon invasion to the Scottish vote to stay in the Union and how that effected England. The author also attempts to cover every aspect of England's long history, from religion to its scientific accomplishments, Magna Carta and parliament to Empire. At times the content seems to slow and getting through the subject matter a real slog in the muck. It may have been my disinterest in that particular subject and another person may find that area enjoyable but a spot that I enjoyed difficult to stay with. The author is largely pro-English, as one would hope a person writing such a tome would be, which gives a different, and at times defensive, tone than is common with books pertaining to England that I get to read here in the states. The narration, though at times droning, was excellent overall. It's difficult to listen to a subject for over forty hours and note start to feel the vocal drone. Overall I greatly enjoyed this book.

27 people found this helpful

A solid, if a bit old fashioned, primer

An ambitious undertaking because of the scope, the author out of necessity glosses over many subjects of interest such as England's relationship with Ireland. The book tries to trace a sense of an English national temperment but generally gives for his examples "great men." To my American ears, about 10% of this book is made of apoligist phrases like "but still better than France and Germany." It seems a bit silly to praise your ancestors for burning slightly fewer witches per capita than rival nations. Then again, I guess it reiterates the theme of an island people anxiously comparing themselves to their continental neighbors.

All this said, this is a history of "the English" and not a history of the people of England, and does a great job at illuminating a few thousand years of the political and economic context of a nation.

26 people found this helpful

I really love and appreciate the authors work

almost brought me to tears. should be required reading. it's very long but worth it.

10 people found this helpful

An Anglophile history of england

If you could sum up The English and Their History in three words, what would they be?

anglophilic political drama

What other book might you compare The English and Their History to and why?

A similar concept, though far more in depth is Churchill's history of the English speaking peoples. Ironically Churchill's history does far less to cover up the insults and atrocities of the English on the world at large. The English and Their History tries to downplay the claims that the English kept a violently imperialist thumb over India and that the the Irish potato famine was exacerbated by the English parliament as a means of genocide.

What about James Langton’s performance did you like?

He adequately captured the often light hearted tone of several of the asides, something often difficult during a long historical reading.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

I was quite fascinated by the authors insights into the development of the English language. He makes a concerted effort to focus on political, social, and literary changes and avoids getting lost in lengthy analyses of wars and battles as many historians do.

Any additional comments?

This book, for the most part, focuses on England after the Norman conquest. If you are looking for an earlier history this is not for you. Also, the author goes all the way up to events in 2013, so if you have an active interest in English or British politics you may want to skip the last 3 hours or so.

18 people found this helpful

Disappointing.

As someone who has eagerly devoured every volume of British history for 30-plus years, I am sorry to write that I was disappointed in this effort. It is very uneven in its treatment of the history of England, and if - like me - you have strong interest in the centuries leading up to 1688, be advised that all of that from the Celts to the Glorious Revolution is flown through in 1/4 of the book. If, however you are most interested in the last 150 years of England, you will find it quite thorough as this takes up the vast majority of the story. Finally, the cheerleading tone and tenor is relentless and overbearing (I am no great fan of revisionist works, but this is far too much English exceptionalism even for me).

One would be far better off with Schama’s A History of Britain or the Oxford History in terms of equitable treatment of epochs and even-handed assessment of exceptionalism.

6 people found this helpful

Simply OUTSTANDING.

I am ready to listen again for another 43 hrs and 15 mins, it is so well narrated. Good job, James Langton!

6 people found this helpful

Outstanding!

Long but worth every minute!
Incredible narration.
Only weakness is poor coverage of the Proteatant Reformation. This section lacked the balanced and enthusiastic coverage of every other subject.

5 people found this helpful

Skips around from century to century.

This could be a great book if the author had taken each century at a time. Instead he jumps from one century to another and back again. Fortunately I have a base knowledge of England to understand the centuries, but it became too tedious to try and follow. This is not for the beginner of England’s history.

9 people found this helpful

Should be called, The English and their politics

As an anglophile, I gobble up British history, unless it's political history. Whig and Tory must be printed 50 times in every chapter. This is a huge book, just note that 20 AD Thru 1680 is a mere quarter of the book while the rest is only through the last world war. To me, that it makes it profoundly unbalanced, and to me, boring.

44 people found this helpful

informative and indepth

there is a lot information given out and it sometimes extremely hard to track what is going on and who is doing what...I retained more when I actually bought the book and could flip pages back and forth...very good read but perhaps to detailed for audio book

3 people found this helpful