Page de couverture de The Fall of Carthage

The Fall of Carthage

The Punic Wars 265-146BC

Aperçu

Obtenez gratuitement l’abonnement Premium Plus pendant 30 jours

14,95 $/mois après l’essai de 30 jours. Annulez à tout moment.
Essayer pour 0,00 $
Autres options d’achat
Acheter pour 7,99 $

Acheter pour 7,99 $

À propos de cet audio

The struggle between Rome and Carthage in the Punic Wars was arguably the greatest and most desperate conflict of antiquity. The forces involved and the casualties suffered by both sides were far greater than in any wars fought before the modern era, while the eventual outcome had far-reaching consequences for the history of the Western World, namely the ascendancy of Rome.

An epic of war and battle, this is also the story of famous generals and leaders: Hannibal, Fabius Maximus, Scipio Africanus, and his grandson Scipio Aemilianus, who would finally bring down the walls of Carthage.

©2000 Adrian Goldsworthy (P)2018 Tantor
Ancienne Militaire Rome Italie Guerre Histoire ancienne Grèce antique
Tout
Les plus pertinents
To be honest, the material in this book is kinda dry - not great for the audiobook format at all - so I can cut Adrian Goldsworthy some slack for writing a textbook-quality academic piece that occasionally lost my attention. To be sure, the material is fascinating: the three Punic wars that resulted in the absolute devastation of a once-powerful North-African Empire that rivaled Egypt & Rome.
Unfortunately, it couldn't rivet my attention for almost 17 hours.

I cannot blame any deficiencies on reader Derek Perkins, however. His narration of the book is characterized by flawless diction, timbre, and cadence.. and a truly pitch-perfect pedagogical tone. This is a fantastic listening product.

Altogether, 'The Fall Of Carthage' merits 9/10-stars even in this limited format. Having taken Classics courses in University, I'm likely a bit spoiled.. and hence cognizant of all that Goldsworthy leaves out. Still, the information-packed book is definitely worth a read. I feel fortunate to have gotten the book on sale as a Daily Deal. True scholars won't find anything new, but interested non-historians like myself won't regret spending the time (or the full Credit if you want to invest it).


[Note: the discussion of military structure + tactics in the Ancient World - particularly naval power in the Mediterranean - is straight-up excellent (some of the best that I have ever heard)]

Great Overview

Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.

Even if you're only interested in Hannibal Barca, this broad examination of the Punic Wars is necessary. By seeing all sides of the conflict - you can truly understand the context the man existed in & appreciate his accomplishments. Can also pick up on subtle details about various cultures/people's of the time - who hold lessons for today. Because author has combined key elements of various primary sources...you get a good foundation. This makes you more confident in pursuing the primary sources on this subject (that can be heavy detailed - and possibly overwhelming if you don't have the foundation this book provides). Final note, despite British narrators being hard to understand sometimes - this one spoke clearly, had good flow, & an authoritative voice.

Great summation of Hannibal Barca's time period

Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.

Fun book to listen to! Great book for anyone looking to learn of the Punic Wars

Great book!

Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.

Captivating book that reads like a historical epic. Leaves you wanting more! Highly recommend this if you are interested in early Roman history.

Perfect Punic War Book

Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.

This is a solid introduction to the Punic Wars. It is firmly based in the ancient sources that survive, which are frequently referred to and evaluated for their reliability. If the present work focuses on battles at the expense of social and cultural considerations, the same is true of Livy and the other sources. Few details are too small for Goldsworthy’s scrutiny, and yet these nowhere hamper the narrative or cloud the big picture. The author is also to be commended for discussing all three Punic Wars together, as well as all the theatres of each war, in such a way that they do not become confused in the reader’s mind. Finally, this book is written for the educated public, and is readily accessible to that audience.

Perkins reads the book well, with a clear, natural and fluid style. His pronunciation of Greek and Latin words is inconsistent, however, and he even mistakes some English words, pronouncing ‘stades’, for example, as a disyllable. Notwithstanding these small errors, the quality of the reading is high, and still pleasant to the ear even after an hour or more of listening.

A good overview based on ancient sources

Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.

Voir plus de commentaires