Only a Pastel Version of the *Beautiful Era*

A beautiful carving is made at the expense of all that is thrown away...a thought that describes this story of the young *ballet rat* that poses for Edgar Degas's sculpture, (Little Dancer of Fourteen) her family, and the Belle Epoque period of France. Behind the beauty of the opera, ballet, and the arts, is the contrast of the discarded and impoverished, their hard and sad lives of struggling to make a living.

The Belle Epoque.."the beautiful era"...Van Gogh, Gaugin, Matisse, Toulouse-Lautrec, Picasso, the birth of Impressionism, the Ballet Russes, Baudelaire, Debussy, Ravel...a primordial soup of creativity in an amazing time. But Painted Girls views only the underbelly of Paris, through the eyes of 3 sisters struggling to pay rent and buy bread--the artists to them are men or patrons who will pay money for *services.* With such a vibrant and creative climate, the author never uses the full palette available, and paints only a watery view of Paris at its artistic height. It ends up being a story that could be told in almost any era.

I thought the first half of the book slow and almost juvenile, told through the younger girl's point of view; then the older sister starts to narrate, and the book quickly goes blue. Definitely not a YA novel! The debauchery the girls have to put up with just to make a living is sad to listen to, and even worse, their acceptance of that fact of life. The focus shifts to the older sister's infatuation with a young man--with all the charm of Bill Sikes--accused of murder. Degas makes just a brief appearance (his sculpture of the girl obviously gained its appreciation after his death), and while a few ballets of the times are mentioned, the listener hears more about the barre work than the lavish productions or famous dancers.

To the patient listener, there is a story, and even some historical bits, but it was much less than what I had anticipated (the 3* overall should probably be 2*)--even with the author's research, and so very slow. The narrator does a good job with the pronunciation of French names, as well as with the different female characters; her attempt at the male voices could have been spared by using Danny Campbell for all of the male parts instead of just the interludes...miniscule issue.

21 people found this helpful

Great concept does not realize its full potential

Buchanan has taken some real historical people - some famous, some infamous, some unknown - woven some facts and some fictional plot twists together to create a unified storyline between some Degas' artwork, some historical figures, and the popular 19th century (and some earlier times) pseudo-scientific theory of physiognomy.. It is a really interesting concept for a novel but it falls short in implementation. The Painted Girls is less historical fiction than a period piece (late 19th century Paris, lower socio economic classes), but it's a period piece that provides only glimpses and not a real picture. More like watching the story unfold through a peephole than through a large window. The plot moves at a good pace (I feared the boredom of The Girl with a Pearl Earring, but that was not the case with The Painted Girls) and I definitely enjoyed the sections of the story that wove the artwork of Degas into the story. But, ultimately, I wasn't drawn into the time period and maybe partly as a result of that, I didn't connect with any of the characters. Frustrating people, often making bad decisions, and I just didn't care what happened to them. Overall, I was entertained and learned a bit from the novel, but it was disappointing that a rather creative concept just didn't quite deliver a KO punch.

The performances by the narrators were satisfactory although there is an obvious challenge in a audiobook when the novel's dialog is in English but spoken by characters who actually would clearly speak French. When you read, your brain kind of finds a place where your imagination makes the bridge for that. But listening to American accents throw around French names and places using French pronunciations right in the middle of a sentence is constantly pulling you out of the setting - it is just kind of distracting. This book might be one that just is better read than heard.

I didn't mind spending a credit on the book, but my recommendation for it would be tepid at best.

9 people found this helpful

Abundance of Misery

This title appealed to me because of the association with Ballet. I have always wanted to learn more about this complex sport/art/science.
This audio started with the story of three sisters in 19th Century France. The story continued along predictable lines by describing the sisters' starvation, constant work at the barre and miserable boarding house living, where they were all crammed into one room with their mother. I continued to listen, waiting for the conflict, the small success or the intriguing character to enter. Short of a couple of appointments with the great artiste, Degas, nothing happened but more suffering. I tired of the constant whining, worrying and grimy encounters with men. There was no reward or romance - just more wailing about circumstances. Also, predictably one sister, working as a laundress, burned a shirt and was "docked one week's wages." Please! How obvious can you be?
I commend anyone who endeavors to write a full-length novel. The technical part - the writing - was well done in this book. Nice description and tone. However, my resources were spent and I expected a fair exchange.

I need something to grab me after the first three hours. I listed to most of the first part, then I quit.

13 people found this helpful

The painted girls

I listened to this book because it was the selection for my book club. I found the story to be very slow to establish. Nearly half the book was devoted to character development before anything really happened. The narrator had a very slow cadence to her narration. I used the audible app to speed up the narration helping me persevere in finishing this book. I found the narrator used an American-type accent that I found confusing when narrating a story about Parisian French girls written by a Canadian author.

2 people found this helpful

Depressing and alluring all at once

There are still things from this book that I wonder about. That may be why I enjoyed it!

2 people found this helpful

Vivid Portrayal of Ballet Girl

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

Yes, I love Degas paintings. I love ballet. I love historical fiction. Great combo!

What was one of the most memorable moments of The Painted Girls?

The ending was by far the best. I won't give it away.

Have you listened to any of the narrators’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

No, this was my first but she is amazing.

If you could rename The Painted Girls, what would you call it?

Something about sisters.

2 people found this helpful

Wonderful Historic Perspective

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

Yes, this book provided so much insight into the times and the lives of the young girls in Paris as well as their plight.

What did you like best about this story?

The changing from perspective of story. From sister to sister.

Have you listened to any of the narrators’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

No, she was truly wonderful.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Yes

2 people found this helpful

Pulls you in

Told from the viewpoints of sisters in an impoverished family with ties to the ballet, the story is surprisingly charming and engrossing -- I say surprisingly because I'm not interested in ballet and don't usually read period fiction. The narrator has a pleasant voice with a likable personality. I would call this elevated light entertainment - you won't learn anything but you won't feel like you've wasted your time on utter fluff, either.

2 people found this helpful

The Painted Girls

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

I would not recommend this book. It failed to hold my interest and I couldn't wait for the
end to come.

If this book were a movie would you go see it?

No

2 people found this helpful

Enjoyable interpretation of historical events

Would you consider the audio edition of The Painted Girls to be better than the print version?

I did not read the print version.

What other book might you compare The Painted Girls to and why?

I don't know.

Which character – as performed by the narrators – was your favorite?

I enjoyed the character of Marie the best. I found there was not a lot of difference between the voice of Marie and the voice of Antoinette. I would have chosen two narrators whose voices were more different.

If you could rename The Painted Girls, what would you call it?

The title is perfect as is but an alternative could be "The Ballet Girls"

Any additional comments?

No.

1 person found this helpful