The competition episode ;)

In this episode of the Hooked on True Crime podcast, hosts Ali and Sarah delve into the fascinating and complex cases of two men named Daniel: Daniel McNaughton and Daniel Sickles. They explore McNaughton's life, his assassination attempt on a government official, and the subsequent trial that established the McNaughton Rules for the insanity defence. The conversation then shifts to Daniel Sickles, a politician whose infidelity led to a dramatic murder trial, marking the first acquittal due to temporary insanity in the United States. The hosts discuss the implications of these cases on legal history, public perception of insanity defences, and the intersection of crime and mental health.

Scottish word of the week : Flenky

Use the code 'hooked' for 10% of Crimecon UK (Manchester, 27th of September 2025)

Join our socials and post the competition answer for a chance to get some HOTC swag.

Sources:

Books:
Moran R. Knowing Right From Wrong: The Insanity Defense of Daniel McNaughtan. The Free Press; 1981.Walk A, West DJ, eds.

Daniel McNaughton: His Trial and the Aftermath. Gaskell Books/Royal College of Psychiatrists; 1977.

Websites:

Daniel McNaughton (1813-1865) - PMCDaniel M’Naghten: The Man Who Changed the Law on Insanity

Report of the trial of Daniel M’Naughton at the Central Criminal Court, Old Bailey (on Friday, the 3rd, and Saturday, the 4th of March, 1843) for the wilful murder of Edward Drummond, Esq / by Richard M. Bousfield and Richard Merrett. | Wellcome Collection

Daniel Sickles: An Unusual Character - Congressional Medal of Honor Society

Murder in Lafayette Square | Headlines & HeroesDaniel Sickles Trial: 1859 | Encyclopedia.com

The 1859 Murder Trial of Daniel E. Sickles - Historical Society of the D.C. CircuitUNITED STATES v. SICKLES.

Caution : this episode contains discussion of rape and violence, plus an anger spawning justice system!

In this episode of 'Hooked on True Crime', hosts Ali and Sarah delve into a harrowing true crime story set on the Greek Island of Corfu, focusing on the case of a young woman who was brutally attacked and raped by a known sex offender. We explore the systemic failures of the criminal justice system that allowed a serial rapist to remain free despite his history of violent attacks. This may be the most evil perpetrator we've ever covered.

Scottish word of the week: Sarah is tested in a quiz and fails!

Ali commits another domestic misdemeanour and we binge watch Destination X, Karen Pirie, and Shetland (BBC)

Used code 'Hooked' for 10% off CrimeConUk Manchester September 27th, 2025.

Sources:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4sluBk4iBTQ

'My Kavos rapist told me - I am a man and I will take what I want' - Grimsby Live

Corfu serial rapist re-arrested and held on new rape charge – The Greek Herald

Corfu rapist who attacked British women holidaymakers sent to prison | Daily Mail Online

Serial rapist known as the Beast of Kavos is back in jail, where he belongs | World | News | Express.co.uk

Serial rapist ‘beast of Kavos’ reportedly falls off cliff while running from police | The Independent | The IndependentSerial rapist

Beast of Kavos breaks back plunging 100ft into Corfu ravine - The Mirror

Serial Rapist Jumps Off Cliff While Running From Police and Breaks Ribs - The New York Times

Corfu serial rapist held on new rape charge | eKathimerini.com

Police show 'rape kit' found after serial rapist 'Beast of Kavos' was arrested - The Mirror

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vOfaK2r5yMw

This week we explore the profound journey of forgiveness and restorative justice following the tragic murder of Christopher Donovan. Ray and Vi Donovan share their experiences of meeting the offenders, the impact of forgiveness on their lives, and the importance of restorative justice in healing both victims and offenders. They emphasize the need for empathy, understanding, and education in preventing crime and fostering a more compassionate society. Through their story, they highlight the transformative power of forgiveness and the potential for change in the lives of those affected by crime.

No domestic crimes committed!

Scottish word of the week: Maukit/Mockit

CrimeCon Uk Manchester 27th of September 2025, we'll be there! Use our code 'Hooked' for 10% off

In this episode of 'Hooked on True Crime', hosts Ali and Sarah engage with the wonderful Ray and Vi Donovan MBEs, who share their harrowing experience following the murder of their son, Chris. The conversation delves into the night of the incident, the emotional turmoil of the hospital experience, the complexities of the court proceedings, and the reflections on justice and forgiveness. The Donovan's discuss the impact of the tragedy on their family, the challenges of navigating the legal system, and their journey towards healing and understanding.

Support/contact Ray and Vi via the Chris Donovan Trust

Use code 'hooked' for 10% discount on CrimeCon UK tickets.

Contact us and join our HOTC family through social media!

Please like, subscribe and support our wee podcast!

In this episode of 'Hooked on True Crime', hosts Ali and Sarah engage with former SIO Colin Sutton, who shares insights from his extensive experience in leading murder investigations, particularly focusing on the tragic case of Chris Donovan. The conversation delves into the complexities of the investigation, the emotional toll on families, and the innovative methods used to present evidence in court. Sutton reflects on the challenges faced during the investigation, the impact of crime on victims' families, and the broader implications of justice and forgiveness in the aftermath of tragedy.

Ali commits a domestic misdemeanour or two!

Scottish word of the week : Feckles

Colin is currently on tour with the Real Manhunter 2, a must see!

He will also be at CrimeCon Manchester, as will we, use code 'hooked' for 10% discount

In this episode of 'Hooked on True Crime', hosts Ali and Sarah discuss the tragic case of Bridget Milton, a hardworking Irish woman who became a victim of a violent crime.

The conversation explores Bridget's background, her struggles as an immigrant, and the circumstances leading to her murder by a soldier. We delve into the investigation, trial, and the societal issues surrounding violence against women, while also reflecting on the personal stories and listener interactions that shape their podcast.

We answer a listeners question about attending Crimecon solo. Use code 'hooked' for 10% off your ticket for Manchester on the 27th of September 2025!

Ali commits, yet another, domestic misdemeanour. Or rather improves on the previous one!

Scottish words of the week : Tapsalteerie and Whigmaleerie

Content Warning: Sarah is outraged and swears in this one! Descriptions of rape and murder.

Join our Hooked on True Crime family on our socials.

https://www.facebook.com/groups/1385112779403649

https://www.instagram.com/hooked_on_true_crime_podcast/

Sources:

https://www.pen-and-sword.co.uk/The-Brookwood-Killers-Paperback/p/51761

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Forty-Years-Murder-Keith-Simpson/dp/B001PKVHCY

In this weeks episode, Ali and Sarah talk with author and true crime producer Tanita Matthew’s about her book, ‘The Murder of Judith Roberts: The mark of Peter Sutcliffe.

They discuss the crimes of Peter Sutcliffe, the man the media dubbed the 'Yorkshire Ripper', covering all of his confirmed victims. Then guided by Tanita, they look into whether Judith Roberts could have been a victim of one of the UKs most notorious serial killers.

In domestic misdemeanours, Sarah calls out her daughter Lily for bringing home the beach and Tanita objects to her lovely partner Tom “Just living his life”.

Scottish word of the week: Drookit

Coming to Crimecon UK Manchester? Use our code 'hooked' for 10% off the cost of your ticket.

The Murder of Judith Roberts : The Mark of Peter Sutcliffe, by Chris Clark and Tanita Matthews (2024), Pen and Sword Publishers (ISBN: 9781399080125)

Avaliable at:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Murder-Judith-Roberts-Peter-Sutcliffe/dp/1399080121

https://www.pen-and-sword.co.uk/The-Murder-of-Judith-Roberts-Hardback/p/50959

Sources:

www.Assets.publishing.service.gov.uk - scanned doc part 2 chronological; sequence of events - Byford Report

www. biography.com/crime/peter-sutcliffe

www.research.tees.ac.uk - 'Revisiting the Yorkshire ripper murders; interogating gender violence, sex work and justice'.

https://www.itv.com/watch/yorkshire-ripper-the-secret-murders/10a0680

Content warning: this episode contains discussion of multiple crimes, murder, and violence.