Shades of Gray Magic - This one's a bit dull

Victoria Schwab starts this high fantasy with a great concept. Four parallel worlds whose only commonality is a central city called London. When Black London is consumed by magic, all the other Londons are sealed off from each other to prevent the spread of the consumption leaving only the Antari who can travel between the 3 remaining Londons. Oh, and there are only two Antari left. One of the Antari, Kell, travels regularly between the Londons delivering messages between the monarchs and doing a bit of smuggling on the side. But Kell's side job leads him into a trap that sets up the plot and introduces him to Lilah who joins him in the adventure.

I think this basic scenario could have been developed into a really interesting tale, but that potentiality is NOT realized. First, it takes a full 4+ hours for the book to progress to the real starting point; more than four hours to find out almost nothing more than I just wrote in that first paragraph! Schwab writes with some classy, lyrical prose, but just doesn't really say much. She is downright stingy with information so you get a lot of description, but little understanding about the characters, the magic system, or the point of anything.

The two Antari, Kell and Holland, seem like they might be interesting, but Schwab seems to want to keep these two so mysterious that you don't get a chance to know them. It's hard to invest in characters you don't know. Lila has a lot more personality, but she's hardly likable. A cut-purse and occasional cut-throat, she's very cavalier about taking a life.

Steven Crossley has a nice voice, clear diction, and decent character voices (fitting accent for Lilah especially). Only one minor bone to pic with the narration. Crossley uses a rather rough voice for the character of Kell which made me picture a man of 35 - 45, but Kell is actually very young. I was shocked to remember this a couple of times when the author referred to the character as a youth or a young man because I kept picturing him as much older due to Crossley's voicing of the character.

Ultimately, I spent 11+ hours with these characters and this story and just never got engaged - at all.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

186 people found this helpful

Not another lame female character

I thoroughly enjoyed the character of Lilah. She was driven by real world needs and not by some stupid infatuation. She is a badass in her own right and can take care of herself in most situations. I liked how the male lead and female lead worked together without wading through layers of sexual tension. A very enjoyable listen.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

129 people found this helpful

social commentary magical high fantasy

I very much enjoyed this book, and not just because I got it free via the Ford Audiobook Club. It's very well written and well-paced, and was an interesting take on the old high fantasy trope. I loved the alternate dimension Londons and how they reflected different emphasis on aspects of humans and their interaction with magic. Kell's story and Lila's were both compelling and richly resonant with the themes of the books: entitlement, responsibility, the search for identity, self-reliance, social commentary, etc. I loved their banter and thought they worked very well as foils for each other. I appreciated that the romance is kept to a minimum, more a loyalty than a swooning uncertainty.

The "feel" of this book in pseudo-high fantasy historical setting, atmosphere , and writing style reminded me of Michael Sullivan's Riyria series, but Schwab put her own stamp on them. Very enjoyable.

The narration by Stephen Crossley was well done, particularly for Kell. I'd have liked a second narrator for Lila, but Crossley did fine for a single person narration.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

93 people found this helpful

How does this have such good reviews?!

This book just is not good. It started to become really apparent by hour 5, but I kept pushing through it, convinced it must get better. It doesn't. People say it has great characters and world building. It doesn't.

Every character is shallow. Their motivations are simplistic. Their shades of grey are non existent. The closest thing to moral conundrums are simple, impulsive choices with no impactful consequence.

There is all this evil magic in the world that is outlawed, but apparently no one to enforce it. There is no mages guild. No magic police. There are mentions of punishments and blocks, but no one is ever hiding the dark magic, yet no one notices it either. In fact, dark magicians encsorcel an entire royal family with ease and there is no royal cabal to catch this out or try to stop it? That's not world building.

The girl in the story has gone her entire life not knowing magic exists. She just accepts it out of nowhere, then makes all these wild guesses about it, and is right, EVERY SINGLE TIME. There's never so much as a mage character saying, "you'd think that, but no. It's actually like this." Nope. She's just intuitively right about everything. That's just lazy writing.

This book is not worth reading. It's not an awful book. But it's not a good one.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

87 people found this helpful

Who picked this narrator?!

Why did they have someone who's 60-70y/o reading for characters who are mostly in their 20's??? Plus he made all the women sound so whiny, every time Lila talked a cringed. Thank god this was free. I'll listen to the second book of they have a different narrator, otherwise I'll just get the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

79 people found this helpful

Why did I wait? Worth the credit!

Kicking myself. I've had this on and off my wish list for over a year because I would read one stellar review and then one that sucked. It's the former - stellar. If you like world-building, dubious characters, and (duh) magic don't delay. This book stands out in the crowd. The slow begining is worth the ending.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

49 people found this helpful

Not my cup of tea

I probably shouldn't even review this since I'm typically not a fantasy genre aficionado. I received this book free as part of the ford audiobook club. I liked lord of the rings, Harry Potter series. Some zombie/vampire books. But to get my attention they have to be smartly written. Keep you thinking. This book seemed like there were no rules. Like the author just wrote and made stuff up as she went. Introducing random rules (like magic has to be verbal) and then breaking those rules in the next chapter with a "hey here's a new rule". It seemed just sort of silly. Maybe I'm just looking at it too literally.

The performance was just fine with the exception of his strange need to rasp out the magical incantations in the same weird voice for every character. It grated on my nerves.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

42 people found this helpful

Great book, could have used 2 narrators

A great first read for a new fantasy world, with interesting characters and excellent world building. The narration was nuanced and smooth, but the one downside is that Crossley has a gravely deep British accent that makes his female characters just a bit tough to identify with. This is one of the sacrifices of single narrators though, and after a while you stop hearing the Monty Python men-dressed-as-women effect!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

39 people found this helpful

Not a fan of the narrator

Would you listen to A Darker Shade of Magic: A Darker Shade of Magic, Book 1 again? Why?

Probably not, at least not until the next one comes out. The story was pretty simple and the narration wasn't great at times in my opinion. It seemed like he missed the tone of a lot of the interactions of the characters at times, though I'm not sure how much of that was me misinterpreting it or him.

What did you like best about this story?

I liked the concept of the story. The idea of multiple London's was cool, and I liked a lot of the backstory of the characters. As far as how events played out in the story, I think there was some weird stuff that happened that maybe wasn't a direction I would have expected but that's not necessarily a bad thing, and it definitely kept things interesting. I was concerned by about the halfway point because it seemed to me like the story was slow to start, but overall I was satisfied with how it turned out. Towards the end I didn't want to put it down.

What did you like about the performance? What did you dislike?

The performance was ok, but at times I found it hard to listen to. For certain things like spell names and words in fictional languages I understand it can be hard to have a good interpretation of what things should sound like, but I definitely found it difficult to stay with the narrator when he was reading them. I appreciated some of the things he added, with details such as a mostly clear voice for each character - though like I mentioned earlier it seemed like the tone was not always conveyed correctly to me. Also accents for some characters sometimes seemed like they were slipping - which I also acknowledge can be difficult to keep straight. It didn't ruin my enjoyment, but there were definitely scenes where it took me out of the moment.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

There were definitely a few moments which made me crack a smile but nothing extreme like laughing or crying.

Any additional comments?

I'd say it is a worthwhile book to pick up if for no other reason than it's a cool concept. I'm probably likely to at least try the second one when it comes out for what it's worth.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

34 people found this helpful

Finally! a great new fantasy book

I'm always looking for a well written fantasy book. And I find them very hard to find. But I really liked this book. She's a great writer and the story is really captivating. The characters are likable and complicated and the world is fantastic. The ideas are rich and the plot keeps twisting and turning. Best of all the author has a strong moral compass and although there are battles and fights--they are fighting for good.
If you love the Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter and even Howl's Moving Castle you will be delighted to discover this great new fantasy book.
I can't wait until the next in this series comes out.
Also, the reader is superb.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

27 people found this helpful